Josh Hart told reporters in Toronto that his mental battle has been “kicking my ass for a couple of weeks now,” a rare public admission from a player who helped anchor the Knicks’ run to the Eastern Conference finals last season.
The 31-year-old wing entered Tuesday’s game against the Raptors shooting career-low percentages across the board and logging his fewest minutes in five seasons, The Athletic reported. Hart finished with five points on 1-of-4 shooting from three-point range and did not play in crunch time, yet called the performance a “step in the right direction” because his body language did not sag.
Shooting slump compounds physical ailments
One finger sits at a near 90-degree angle — surgery would likely end his playing career — and a September calf injury kept him out of training camp before an ankle issue and lingering knee trouble followed, The Athletic reported.
Contract year adds pressure but not the root cause
New York holds a team option on Hart for next season, and the Knicks sit 8-6 with a payroll that could push them into the second apron, forcing difficult roster decisions. Hart acknowledged the situation sits in the back of his mind but called it “low-hanging fruit” for his struggles.
“When you start focusing on those things, negative outcomes happen,” he told reporters in Toronto, per The Athletic.

Echoes of a previous rut
Roughly a year ago, Hart questioned whether he belonged in the starting lineup after a string of poor games. He worked through that stretch and became a linchpin of a unit that helped New York end a 53-year championship drought. This time, he said, past proof offers little comfort in the moment.
“When you’re in the middle of it, there’s not much that can really help,” Hart said. “At the end of the day … today, I think I had a little bit better of a spirit.”
Small signs of progress in Toronto
Against the Raptors, Hart did not argue with officials, apologized to teammates after mistakes, and delivered a clutch basket, a hustle play for an extra possession, and a decisive pass for an open teammate — all within a 90-second span. He framed the night as process over results.
“For me, this (rough patch) is a little harder because I’m trying to get the mental aspect right and the physical aspect right,” Hart said. “It can be easier when you’re just dealing with one of those things. … I’m battling both of those things. I’m trying to give myself a little bit of grace with that.”
Why Hart’s mindset matters for New York’s ceiling
The Knicks’ best lineups rely on Hart’s unique ability to swing games without a play called for him. The Athletic wrote that it’s impossible to pour from an empty cup, summarizing the stakes for a team built around his glue-guy impact.
Frequently asked questions
What are Josh Hart’s shooting numbers this season compared to last year?
Hart shot a career-high 41.3 percent from three-point range last season. This season he is posting career-low percentages across the board, though exact season-to-date splits were not disclosed in the reporting.
Is Hart’s contract situation the main reason for his struggles?
Hart said the team option for next season is “low-hanging fruit” and not the root cause, though he acknowledged it sits in the back of his mind during a contract year.
What physical issues is Hart managing?
He has a finger bent at roughly 90 degrees that cannot be fixed without likely ending his career, plus a calf injury that wiped out training camp, an ankle issue, and chronic knee trouble.
Toronto, where Hart spoke to reporters, is Canada’s most populous city and the fourth-largest in North America, with 2,794,356 residents in 2021. The area has been inhabited for more than 10,000 years; the town of York was established in 1793 and renamed Toronto when incorporated in 1834. About half of its current population was born outside Canada, and over 160 languages are spoken there.
How did Hart describe his mindset after the Toronto game?
He called it a “step in the right direction,” noting he kept his head up, avoided arguing with referees, and focused on process rather than his five-point, 1-of-4 stat line.