Kidney Study Challenges Dialysis Default: Bristol’s Prof Caskey

Dialysis should not be the automatic default treatment option for older people experiencing kidney failure, according to a nine-year study involving almost 500 patients published by BBC News.

The research, led by the University of Bristol, examined whether managing symptoms in a less medicalised way could offer a viable alternative without compromising a person’s overall quality and length of life. Most participants in the study were over the age of 80 and often dealt with complex health problems such as heart disease and cancer.

“Our findings could have global implications for how kidney failure is discussed and managed in older patients,” project lead Professor Fergus Caskey said. Caskey, a kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, added that patients ought to be informed about the pros and cons of both treatments so they can choose an approach fitting their personal care priorities.

Rather than receiving automatic dialysis, patients in the randomised study were allocated to one of two distinct approaches: preparation for dialysis or preparation for responsive management at home. Over an average follow-up period of 4.5 years, the research showed that neither approach resulted in superior outcomes when considering length and quality of life together.

Clinical Care Comparisons

Participants in both trial groups were actually more likely to die from other causes than to require dialysis, highlighting the vulnerability and complex health needs of this specific population. Caskey said that while dialysis is life-saving for younger individuals, it remains a huge undertaking.

A picture of a medical worker's hand which are in purple gloves holding a red tubes due to dialysis treatment
Photo: bbc.com

“It is life-saving for younger people but it is a huge undertaking for patients,” Fergus Caskey said.

Standard hospital dialysis typically involves traveling to a clinic three times a week for at least four hours per session, which can prove exhausting for older patients. Older people generally do not recover from kidney failure or come off dialysis once treatment begins.

The study found that a structured programme of care focused on managing kidney failure symptoms at home can achieve similar overall results in quality and length of life. “neither treatment option was superior to the other, but both provided similar overall length and quality of life,” Caskey, a kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, said.

Patient Experiences in South Gloucestershire

Lynn Watts, 77, from Kingswood in South Gloucestershire, initially thought the end was near when she was diagnosed with kidney failure nearly five years ago. She initially decided she would undergo dialysis if her symptoms progressed, but she wanted to avoid losing three days every week to hospital visits.

Treatment options for older people with kidney failure: the Prepare for Kidney Care study results — Bristol NHS Foundation Trust

“I didn’t want three days taken out of my life every week,” Lynn Watts said.

Watts became involved in the study in January 2024 and was randomly chosen as one of the patients offered an alternative to dialysis. Her kidney function has remained fairly stable since then.

“It’s slowed my life down,” Watts told BBC News, adding that she no longer runs about and gardens as she once did. “I’m still alive and that’s how I look at it.”

There are 7.2 million people across the UK living with some level of chronic kidney disease, mostly at the earliest stages, according to data from the charity Kidney Care UK. Fiona Loud from the charity said the research offers an opportunity to evaluate treatment balances against what patients value most toward the end of their lives.

Chronic Kidney Disease Questions

Who led the kidney failure treatment study?

The nine-year research project was led by the University of Bristol, with project lead Professor Fergus Caskey, a kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust.

How many patients participated in the research?

The study involved almost 500 patients, with the majority of participants being over the age of 80 and many managing other health conditions like cancer and heart disease.

What alternatives to hospital dialysis were tested?

Participants were randomly allocated to either preparation for hospital dialysis or preparation for responsive management at home, focusing on symptom control without intensive medicalisation.

What did Kidney Care UK say about the findings?

Fiona Loud from Kidney Care UK said that the research allows patients to examine treatment balances against personal values toward the end of life to make flexible, informed choices.