Labour is procrastinating over policy as UK’s economy goes backwards | Phillip Inman

by Rachel Morgan News Editor

Labour’s Christmas celebrations are being eclipsed by a stark economic picture, with the latest data showing the UK economy shrinking and prompting talk of a mild recession among City bankers.

Weakening economy and rising pressures

Unemployment is climbing and businesses remain hesitant to invest, leaving the economy “stuck in first gear”. In this gloomy climate, many Labour MPs are unlikely to feel comfortable raising their glasses in celebration.

Whitehall’s response, as described by insiders, is dominated by “procrastination” when it comes to boosting the economy.

New business rates regime hits small pubs

Since last month’s budget, Treasury officials have rolled out a new business rates system that pubs and hotels will have to apply from April. The regime was assembled without clear road‑testing, according to industry observers.

Small, independent pub chains warn that their rates could soar by 500 % or more for a single outlet. A grassroots campaign that began at the Larder House pub in Bournemouth now displays more than 200 signs outside local taverns, bearing the #taxedout slogan.

James Fowler, owner of the Larder House, called the changes a “devastating blow”. Andy Lennox, who runs three pubs and three restaurants in Dorset, echoed the sentiment, noting that his business rates are set to rise 126 % by 2028 after a year that generated £1.5 m in revenue but only £50,000 profit.

Farm inheritance tax proposal

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is pushing a new inheritance tax levy for farmers, slated to start next April. Critics argue the measure will force many farms to be sold, likely to private‑equity firms or foreign buyers.

Farmers contend the levy is overly burdensome and fails to recognise the sector’s unique reliance on expensive land and thin profit margins.

Family businesses face new IHT charges

After four decades of exemption, family‑owned businesses are now required to pay inheritance tax. Previously, assets were deemed “worthless” as long as the business remained operational, with tax only applying upon sale.

The sudden policy shift comes amid a cost‑of‑living crisis, making it difficult for family firms to publicly campaign on the issue.

Political dynamics and decision‑making

Labour’s long‑term project framework, described as a ten‑year plan, encourages extensive meetings and delayed decisions. This clashes with advisers to Keir Starmer, who reportedly evaluate every policy through an “election MRI scanner” to gauge its electoral appeal for upcoming local elections and the 2029 general election.

Analysts note that the tension between prolonged deliberation and short‑term electoral calculations could stall key initiatives such as the industrial strategy, new towns, local‑government reform and public investment.

Did You Know? The #taxedout protest originated at the Larder House pub in Bournemouth and has already spread to over 200 signs outside pubs across the country.
Expert Insight: The combination of a sluggish economy, sudden tax hikes on sectors that operate on razor‑thin margins, and a decision‑making process that prioritises electoral optics over thorough analysis creates a perfect storm. If unchecked, these pressures could accelerate the erosion of small‑business viability and undermine Labour’s broader economic agenda.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the new business rates regime and who does it affect?

The regime, introduced in the budget last month and effective from April, alters the calculation of business rates for pubs and hotels. Small, independent pub chains say it could increase their rates by up to 500 %.

Why are farmers opposed to the proposed inheritance tax levy?

Farmers argue that the levy, set to start next April, would make it difficult to pass land to the next generation and could force sales to private‑equity or foreign buyers, despite the sector’s reliance on costly land and slim margins.

How might Labour’s internal decision‑making affect policy implementation?

Labour’s ten‑year planning approach encourages prolonged meetings, while advisers seek to filter every decision through an “election MRI scanner”. This conflict may delay or dilute policies such as the industrial strategy and public investment plans.

How do you think these tax changes will shape the outlook for small businesses and farms in the coming year?

You may also like

Leave a Comment