The Evolving Role of the Seasoned CIO: Navigating the Next Chapter
For decades, Chief Information Officers (CIOs) have faced complex challenges. But as careers mature, the obstacles don’t disappear – they simply change. Experienced IT leaders often find their ability to learn new technologies and adapt to rapid change undervalued, or encounter age-related biases. A restructuring can create re-entry particularly difficult, compounded by a shrinking job market, age discrimination, and competition from younger tech executives.
Planning for Transition: The Two-to-Three Year Horizon
Bill Ballentine, former CIO of Indiana University of Pennsylvania (IUP) with 36 years in the IT industry, emphasizes proactive planning. After 18 years as CIO at IUP, and concurrently as a technology executive within the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education for the last 11, he transitioned to a part-time IT consulting business, ‘Haven Hill Services.’
“At 59, I wasn’t ready to leave the industry. I wanted to continue working in the higher education IT executive space, but as a contractor, part-time only,” Ballentine explained. Finding the right balance – projects that aligned with his preferences – proved challenging. He discovered that larger consulting firms offered opportunities, but often required compromising on his desired conditions. He found a suitable remote-focused role with predictable hours and contract terms.
He highlights the importance of starting to plan for this transition two to three years before retirement. “Knowing the timeframe and the income you demand allows you to determine how strict you can be with your work preferences.”
Ballentine focused on answering five key questions:
- How many hours per month are you willing to work?
- How much travel and on-site work are you willing to accept?
- Are you open to industries outside of higher education?
- Will you work as an employee, or only as a contractor?
- In what areas of IT consulting can you deliver value?
He used these answers as a filter for incoming inquiries.
Sharing Wisdom: The Value of Experience
Steve Agnoli, a veteran with 22 years as a CIO in global law firms, and a recipient of the CIO 100 Award, founded ‘SWA Executive Consulting’ in 2024. He leverages his experience in business and IT transformation to help clients improve performance, guarantee technology and process investment returns, and build multidisciplinary teams.
Agnoli describes himself as “semi-retired” and also serves as a senior instructor at Carnegie Mellon University’s ‘CIDO Executive Program,’ mentoring the next generation of IT leaders. He focuses on helping organizations enhance their digital and IT capabilities, streamline processes, and ensure business value from technology investments.
Agnoli’s advice to seasoned CIOs is clear: assess your strengths, differentiators, value proposition, and what truly excites you. “Structure that capability in a way that benefits others,” he urges. “Time is short. Don’t spend it on things you don’t enjoy; focus on what is most valuable to others and most enjoyable for you.”
The Boardroom Beckons: A Path to Continued Engagement
Lisa Rogers, with extensive experience in leadership, business transformation, and IT strategy, believes her current role at Modern Technology Solutions will be her last full-time position. She previously served as CIO at Oteemo and Dewberry.
Rogers is actively pursuing opportunities on corporate boards and advisory committees focused on workforce development. She notes that securing a first board seat is similar to landing a C-level role. She also acknowledges experiencing age bias during her search. “The question was always, ‘Can you still contribute something new and innovative at this age?’”
She emphasizes the importance of consistently exceeding expectations and delivering results to build trust and demonstrate competence. Networking and maintaining strong professional relationships are also crucial. Rogers stresses that treating people well remains a core principle. “Good people attract good opportunities. They’re the ones who lift you up when you fall and offer protection when you need it.”
Rogers advises those considering board positions to start looking in their 50s, citing the “72-year rule” – the expectation that board members will retire around age 72. She recommends programs like those offered by the National Association of Corporate Directors (NACD) to prepare for board service.
The Interim CIO Route: A Flexible Option
Bruce Tagert chose a different path, taking on interim CIO roles at Oregon State University and Juniata College after a 26-year career as a CIO. He currently serves as Interim Vice President and CIO at Worcester State University and chairs the board of the Pennsylvania Research and Education Network (KeystoneREN).
Tagert believes the role of the CIO has evolved from a technical expert to a strategic leader and planner. He emphasizes the importance of organizational development, IT workforce management, alignment with university leadership, and understanding the future of higher education. He also encountered age bias, with potential employers questioning his ability to contribute innovative ideas. He stresses that demonstrating leadership, strategic planning, and vision are more important than years of IT management experience.
FAQ
Q: Is age discrimination a significant issue for experienced CIOs?
A: Yes, it can be. Many experienced CIOs report facing age-related biases during their job search.
Q: What is the best way to prepare for a career transition after being a CIO?
A: Start planning 2-3 years in advance, assess your skills and preferences, and consider options like consulting, interim roles, or board positions.
Q: What skills are most valuable for a seasoned CIO seeking new opportunities?
A: Leadership, strategic planning, vision, and the ability to demonstrate value beyond technical expertise.
Q: Are board positions a viable option for retired CIOs?
A: Yes, but preparation is key. Consider programs like those offered by the NACD to gain the necessary skills and knowledge.
Did you recognize? The role of the CIO is increasingly focused on strategic leadership and business transformation, rather than purely technical expertise.
Pro Tip: Networking is crucial. Maintain strong relationships with colleagues and industry peers to uncover new opportunities.
Ready to explore more insights on IT leadership? Browse our other articles or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates.
