Efforts to manufacture consumer goods like board games in the United States face significant structural hurdles, including fragmented supply chains and higher production costs. According to Jonathan Silva, CEO of WS Game Company, attempting to produce a special edition Monopoly game domestically resulted in doubled manufacturing costs and a year-long assembly timeline due to the lack of a centralized factory ecosystem.
The Hidden Costs of Domestic Toy Production
For toy manufacturers, moving production back to the U.S. is often constrained by the absence of specialized infrastructure. When WS Game Company attempted to produce its Americana edition Monopoly game domestically, the company encountered immediate supply chain gaps. Silva noted that while he successfully sourced boards from a former Hasbro facility in Massachusetts and game tokens from an Indiana-based firm, the lack of domestic manufacturers for small components like dice proved prohibitive.
“We turned over every single leaf trying to find someone who would make 10,000 dice for us in the U.S.,” Silva said. The effort ultimately required sourcing those components from abroad. Because Chinese manufacturers typically house all necessary production capabilities under one roof, the U.S. alternative required managing multiple vendors, which Silva reported consumed excessive resources and time.
Did you know?
Approximately 80% of all toys and games sold in the United States are manufactured in China, according to data from The Toy Association.
Why Industry Experts See Limited Reshoring Potential
The economic reality of the toy industry makes domestic manufacturing difficult to scale. Greg Ahearn, president and CEO of The Toy Association, explains that the industry relies on a factory ecosystem that has been built over decades. For most toys, which are characterized by low price points and thin profit margins, the capital investment required to build new domestic plants is considered economically unfeasible by many in the sector.
“Even if you could, who in their right mind would take their capital and invest it into creating a toy manufacturing plant?” Ahearn said. Consequently, industry groups are currently lobbying for tariff carve-outs. The U.S.–China Board of Trade is evaluating proposals that could allow up to $30 billion worth of Chinese-made products to enter the U.S. tariff-free, though toys must compete with other categories like apparel and footwear for these exemptions.
Balancing Domestic Ambition with Global Trade Realities
Despite the challenges of his domestic experiment, Silva continues to produce the bulk of his inventory in China. The company is currently awaiting a $6 million shipment of games for the upcoming holiday season, facing uncertainty regarding the final tariff bill. This highlights a broader trend: while domestic production is possible for niche or commemorative high-end items, the mass-market toy business remains heavily dependent on established international supply chains.
Silva remains pragmatic about the limits of domestic production. “We’re really good at a lot of great things here in America,” he noted. “But we’re not really great at making certain items that are consumable goods.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is it difficult to manufacture toys in the U.S.?
According to The Toy Association, the U.S. lacks the specialized factory ecosystem that China has developed over decades, which allows for the efficient, low-cost production of complex components like dice and game tokens.
What are the primary financial risks for toy companies importing from China?
Companies face uncertainty regarding tariff bills, which can add millions of dollars to the cost of goods. This unpredictability makes it difficult for companies to forecast pricing and maintain profit margins on low-cost items.
Are there any successful examples of domestic toy manufacturing?
Yes, specialized components such as game boards and custom metal tokens can be produced in the U.S. by niche manufacturers, though the process often involves coordinating multiple vendors rather than a single production facility.
Have you noticed changes in the origin of the products you purchase? Share your thoughts in the comments below, or subscribe to our newsletter for more updates on global trade and manufacturing trends.
Worth a look
