Lucy Recovers £750 After Currys Sends Dummy iPhone

An iPhone purchase turned into a repeated dispute after a customer received a dummy handset instead of the device she bought, according to the BBC.

Lucy bought the Apple phone for £750 from the Currys store in Carlisle. The box contained a non-working model rather than the genuine smartphone. She sent the package back to arrange a return.

When the replacement arrived, it was the identical fake phone. She tried the returns process a second time, only to receive the same dummy handset again.

Currys declined to issue a refund despite her repeated attempts. She ultimately recovered her money through her bank.

Currys Sends Used MacBook as Replacement

A broader BBC Watchdog investigation uncovered similar complaints involving high-value electronics sold by the retailer. Andrew spent £2,700 on an Apple MacBook from Currys, selecting a black model. He instead received a silver laptop bearing marks from old stickers.

When the retailer asked him to return it, Andrew sent the machine back. A replacement arrived shortly afterward. He took the new package to a Currys store and recorded himself opening it. The laptop inside was the exact same machine he had returned three weeks earlier.

In another case, Lee paid £3,300 for an Apple MacBook from the Currys store in Aldershot. He opened his delivery to find two bags of rice instead of a computer. He contacted Apple and learned that the device’s 12-month warranty had already been activated 16 days before his purchase. Currys declined to reopen his complaint, but Lee eventually recovered his money through his bank, which Currys is reimbursing.

Electronics Purchase Discrepancies
Customer Item Ordered Price Paid Item Received
Lucy iPhone £750 Dummy handset
Andrew Apple MacBook £2,700 Used silver laptop
Lee Apple MacBook £3,300 Two bags of rice

Retailer Response to Fraud Allegations

The incidents showed how returned products reach other customers without proper checks. The investigation examined whether criminals were swapping expensive electronics for cheaper items before returning the packages.

High-value devices like smartphones and laptops attract theft because the price difference is substantial. If returned parcels are not thoroughly inspected, substituted goods can re-enter stock and sell to unsuspecting buyers at full price.

When Watchdog brought these claims to Currys, the company responded by highlighting that it assists millions of shoppers annually across both its physical shops and digital platforms. The retailer described cases where customers received incorrect orders as exceptionally rare and stated it would investigate such incidents to make sure they were put right.

Questions About Electronics Returns

How did customers recover their money after Currys declined refunds?

Lucy and Lee both recovered their money through their respective banks after Currys initially declined to issue refunds directly. Currys subsequently agreed to reimburse the bank for Lee’s payment.

Why did the replacement laptops have active warranties?

Checks conducted during the investigation revealed that the devices had their warranties activated weeks before the customers purchased them. Andrew’s laptop warranty was activated 19 days prior, while Lee’s MacBook warranty was activated 16 days before his purchase.

The investigation looked into whether a retail fraud scheme might be taking place, with wrongdoers substituting costly tech goods for inexpensive alternatives prior to sending the boxes back.