The Carolina Hurricanes’ failed attempt to acquire Matthew Tkachuk in 2022 fundamentally altered the trajectory of the NHL, influencing major transactions including the Mikko Rantanen trade to the Colorado Avalanche. According to NHL insider Elliotte Friedman, the Hurricanes offered a package centered on Martin Necas and prospect Alexander Nikishin to the Calgary Flames, a move that would have reshaped the Western Conference power structure.
How the Flames’ 2022 decision rippled through the league
The Calgary Flames ultimately rejected the Carolina offer in favor of a trade with the Florida Panthers. As reported on the 32 Thoughts podcast, the Hurricanes’ proposed package included Martin Necas, Alexander Nikishin, first-round draft picks, and salary relief for Jake Gardiner. Instead, the Flames accepted a deal featuring Jonathan Huberdeau and Mackenzie Weegar.
This decision created a massive disparity in long-term results. While Tkachuk led the Panthers to three consecutive Stanley Cup Finals and two championships, the Flames’ acquisition of Huberdeau failed to yield similar production. This trade failure directly impacted the free agency market, particularly the recruitment of Nazem Kadri, who signed with Calgary only after the team signaled a commitment to contending with their new roster additions.
Before joining the Colorado Avalanche, Nazem Kadri waited five weeks into free agency to sign with the Flames, specifically seeking a roster capable of winning a Stanley Cup. His decision was heavily influenced by the presence of high-profile additions like Huberdeau and Weegar.
Why Martin Necas became a high-value trade target
Martin Necas emerged as a primary trade asset because of his blend of youth and proven production. By the summer of 2022, Necas had established himself as a reliable top-nine forward, having posted three consecutive seasons with at least 36 points. According to reports, Colorado Avalanche general manager Chris MacFarland prioritized acquiring Necas in the Mikko Rantanen blockbuster deal to ensure the team remained competitive in the Western Conference.
MacFarland’s urgency was driven by external interest. Reports indicate the Vancouver Canucks were actively pursuing Necas as a centerpiece for a package involving star center Elias Pettersson. By finalizing the deal for Necas, the Avalanche effectively blocked a major move by a direct conference rival.
What are the long-term consequences for Carolina and Colorado?
The failed Tkachuk trade may have inadvertently helped the Hurricanes build a championship-winning culture. By retaining Necas, the Hurricanes maintained a roster core that eventually secured a Stanley Cup title in 2026. This stability allowed the franchise to remain a premier destination in the Eastern Conference, a status they share with the Florida Panthers.
For the Avalanche, the acquisition of Necas represents a strategic pivot. Had the Flames accepted the Carolina offer four years ago, the ripple effects could have changed where players like Kadri landed and whether the Hurricanes would have felt the need to pursue subsequent high-profile trades like the one for Rantanen.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Flames choose the Florida offer over Carolina’s?
The Flames opted for the package centered on Jonathan Huberdeau and Mackenzie Weegar, likely prioritizing immediate veteran impact and defensive depth at the time of the trade.
How did the failed Tkachuk trade affect Nazem Kadri?
Kadri sought a contender for his next contract. The addition of Huberdeau and Weegar made Calgary appear to be a championship-caliber team, influencing Kadri to sign there rather than seeking a lower-paying deal with the Avalanche.
What was the main component of the trade offer for Matthew Tkachuk?
According to Elliotte Friedman, the Hurricanes’ offer was headlined by Martin Necas and prospect Alexander Nikishin, along with additional draft capital and salary considerations.
Stay up to date with the latest roster moves and analysis by subscribing to our weekly newsletter, or explore our archives for more deep-dive investigations into NHL trade history.
