Minkah Fitzpatrick was traded to Miami following a stark decline in defensive production with the Pittsburgh Steelers, where the safety registered zero turnovers in 2023 and just one interception in 2024. Acquired via trade from the Miami Dolphins in 2019, Fitzpatrick initially recorded five interceptions and earned first-team All-Pro honors, piling up 18 interceptions and three All-Pro selections between 2019 and 2022 before his splash plays abruptly stopped.
Role Stagnation and Deep-Safety Constraints in Pittsburgh
According to Fitzpatrick’s appearance on The Pivot, the defensive back believes he stagnated because the Steelers locked him into a rigid deep-safety role. After starting his career doing varied work, Pittsburgh deployed him primarily at post safety and half safety. “When I first got there, they just plugged me in at post safety, half safety. And I played well there. After awhile, quarterbacks aren’t going to be throwing you the ball a whole lot,” Fitzpatrick told The Pivot. He noted that opposing signal-callers simply started throwing away from his side of the field.
Fitzpatrick explained that his initial success created a trap where the coaching staff refused to move him around. “They got so used to me being in that role and doing a good job of it, that they didn’t remember, or they didn’t really care to move me around, so I just stuck in that role,” he said. While he maintained high tackle numbers—recording 96 or more tackles every year except one from 2021 to 2024—his role as the last line of defense meant making tackles downfield after busted runs rather than forcing turnovers.
Did You Know? Between 2019 and 2022, Fitzpatrick racked up 18 interceptions and three first-team All-Pro nods, but saw his turnover production drop to zero in 2023 and just one in 2024.
Regrets Over Communication and Missed Conversations
Fitzpatrick admitted he harbors regrets about how he handled his utilization in Pittsburgh, wishing he had spoken up sooner. “In Pittsburgh, I definitely regret the way I handled the situation,” he said on The Pivot. Rather than requesting a schematic change from the coaching staff, he chose to “bite the bullet” while the team continued to bring in other personnel who lacked his positional flexibility.
According to analysis from BVM Sports, this situation highlights how critical communication regarding player roles is to maximizing both individual output and team success. Fitzpatrick believes his capabilities are best utilized when he can move across different alignments, noting that the Steelers ultimately wanted splash plays while paying him a top safety salary of $18 million.
The Trade to Miami and Roster Turnover
In an ironic twist of roster management, the Steelers traded Fitzpatrick to Miami in exchange for Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith. Pittsburgh specifically valued Ramsey for his versatility, utilizing him across the slot and at safety. BVM Sports notes that Fitzpatrick began his professional career as a slot corner in Miami before the Steelers permanently moved him to deep safety.
Now back with the Dolphins, Fitzpatrick aims to recapture the dynamic playmaking that defined his early career. Whether he can fully reclaim his high-volume interception numbers outside of Pittsburgh remains to be seen as he steps into a more versatile defensive scheme.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Minkah Fitzpatrick’s interceptions decline in Pittsburgh?
According to Fitzpatrick, opposing quarterbacks stopped throwing in his direction after he established himself as a dominant deep safety. He stated that being pigeonholed in a rigid post-safety role limited his opportunities to make splash plays.
What were Minkah Fitzpatrick’s stats with the Steelers?
From 2019 to 2022, Fitzpatrick intercepted 18 passes and earned three first-team All-Pro selections. He recorded zero interceptions in 2023, one interception in 2024, and consistently registered 96 or more tackles every year except one between 2021 and 2024.
Who was involved in the trade sending Fitzpatrick to Miami?
The Steelers traded Minkah Fitzpatrick to the Miami Dolphins in exchange for Jalen Ramsey and Jonnu Smith.
Want more exclusive NFL analysis and player trade breakdowns? Subscribe to our newsletter or drop a comment below to share your thoughts on Fitzpatrick’s tenure in Pittsburgh.