Major League Baseball has officially cracked down on New York Yankees utilityman Oswaldo Caballero’s batter’s box routine, instructing umpires to issue pitch-clock violations rather than warnings for his habit of delaying his readiness. The league cited its Pace of Game Procedures, which categorize intentional delays designed to deceive a pitcher as a form of "circumvention."
MLB Enforcement and the "Circumvention" Rule
The league’s decision follows a series of on-field disputes regarding the timing of Caballero’s at-bats. According to crew chief Adrian Johnson, the enforcement was a direct response to a bench-clearing incident during a game against the Pittsburgh Pirates. Umpires received specific instructions from MLB to penalize the behavior immediately.
"We were instructed not to warn him. We were instructed to violate him," Johnson said.
The league points to a specific provision in the Pace of Game Procedures that prohibits "conduct by batters designed to deceive a pitcher into beginning their windup or coming to the set position." Plate umpire Quinn Wolcott, who assessed a violation against Caballero in the sixth inning of a recent doubleheader, noted that the batter’s tendency to look down until eight seconds remain on the clock is unique among current hitters.
Impact on Game Flow and Player Perspective
The crackdown has led to significant delays. During a June 14 game in Toronto, a dispute over Caballero’s timing caused a stoppage of more than two minutes. A similar 2.5-minute delay occurred during the Wednesday game against Pittsburgh, which ultimately saw Caballero take a called third strike with a runner on base.
Caballero maintains that he is being unfairly singled out for a routine he has used consistently. "I’m not trying to trick someone because I do the same thing over and over," Caballero said. He expressed concern that the ruling grants pitchers too much control over the timing of the at-bat, potentially leaving him at a disadvantage if a pitcher decides to hold the ball.
Managerial Reaction and Strategic Adjustments
Yankees manager Aaron Boone described the league’s sudden shift in policy as "embarrassing," noting that the team was not informed of the change before the game. Despite his frustration with the ruling, Boone has instructed Caballero to adjust his timing.
"Make sure you’re looking up at nine so that you are alert by eight," Boone said.
This adjustment is a significant change in stance for Boone, who previously viewed Caballero as a "pest" during his time with the Tampa Bay Rays. The Yankees acquired Caballero on July 31, and Boone has since praised his contributions as a player, despite the ongoing friction with league officials over his habits.
Did you know?
MLB instituted the pitch clock in 2023 to reduce total game times. As of 2024, the clock is set to 15 seconds with no runners on base and 18 seconds with runners on base.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Oswaldo Caballero penalized?
Umpires penalized Caballero for violating Pace of Game Procedures. MLB determined his routine of looking down until the final seconds of the pitch clock was intended to deceive the pitcher, which the league classifies as circumvention.
What is the "circumvention" rule in MLB?
The rule prohibits batters from engaging in behavior specifically designed to trick a pitcher into starting their windup or set position in violation of pitch-clock regulations.
Has the league addressed similar behaviors before?
Yes. In 2023, MLB issued a memo warning batters not to keep a foot out of the box. That rule was colloquially referred to by players like Willson Contreras as "the Willson rule."
What is the standard pitch clock duration?
Pitchers have 15 seconds to deliver a pitch when the bases are empty and 18 seconds when runners are on base.
Have thoughts on the pitch clock? Join the conversation in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for more updates on MLB rule changes and team news.
Keep reading