Myanmar ICJ Genocide Ruling Could Impact Israel Case

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled on Thursday that Myanmar is responsible for committing genocide against the Rohingya people, marking the first time the UN’s highest court has held a state accountable for the crime itself rather than merely for failing to prevent it.

A majority of nine out of 15 judges concluded that the sum of killings, destruction, mass displacement and hate rhetoric proved genocidal intent, rejecting Myanmar’s argument that its 2017 offensive was a legitimate operation against armed insurgents.

“Genocide. That is the ICJ’s unambiguous conclusion,” said Agnès Callamard, Secretary General of Amnesty International, describing the verdict as a historic and credible acknowledgment of the atrocities against the Rohingya after years of denial and impunity, according to Utrop.

Legal experts say the judgment lowers the evidentiary threshold for proving genocidal intent and could strengthen the separate case brought by South Africa accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza. “The threshold that the majority of judges in the ICJ have laid down to establish genocidal intent in the Myanmar case has been lowered considerably compared to previous cases,” said Cecilie Hellestveit, who holds a doctorate in international law and is a professor at the University of Bristol, speaking to Aftenposten.

Hellestveit also said she worries that the ICJ is setting such a low threshold that warring parties will get a perverse incentive to brutalise an enemy’s warfare against their own areas.

The ruling, delivered on November 19, 2026, comes nine years after Myanmar’s military launched a brutal crackdown in Rakhine State in August 2017. Around 10,000 civilians were killed, villages were burned, and more than 700,000 Rohingya were driven into Bangladesh, where roughly one million now live in overcrowded camps in Cox’s Bazar.

Gambia filed the case at the ICJ in 2019 with backing from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. Myanmar’s authorities revoked the Rohingya’s citizenship in 1982 and refused to recognise them as one of the country’s official ethnic minorities. The military claimed the 2017 offensive was a response to attacks by the Rohingya insurgent group ARSA on police and military posts.

In the courtroom, the judges detailed killings, torture and sexual violence, including against children and infants, for three hours. “Genocide. That is the ICJ’s unambiguous conclusion,” said Agnès Callamard, Secretary General of Amnesty International, describing the verdict as a historic and credible acknowledgment of the atrocities against the Rohingya after years of denial and impunity, according to Utrop – den flerkulturelle avisen.

The court dismissed Myanmar’s defence that it was targeting only armed groups. “The Court finds that a state can have multiple purposes simultaneously. Even if a military attack is directed at armed insurgents, that does not exclude a simultaneous intent to destroy a people,” said Terje Einarsen, professor of law at the University of Bergen and one of Norway’s leading experts on international courts, speaking to NRK.

Einarsen told TV 2 he has long believed Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, and said that the ICJ also clarified that forced displacement and deportation are not arguments against genocide but can indicate genocidal intent.

Einarsen is a board member of ICJ Norway and stated in March 2024 that he believed Israel was committing genocide, later substantiated in a commentary. He has also taken on an assignment as counsel for the Palestine Committee regarding the Oil Fund’s investments in Israel.

Bjørn Winquist, chair of the association Defend International Law, told NTB that for the South Africa case against Israel it is particularly important that the court rejected the notion that a declared military purpose in itself excludes genocidal intent. He added that a final judgment on Israel’s responsibility is unlikely before 2030 at the earliest. A final decision in the case is therefore not expected before around 2030. By comparison, it took seven years from when Gambia filed the ICJ suit against Myanmar over the Rohingya until a judgment arrived.

Both Einarsen and Hellestveit believe the judgment against Myanmar is bad news for Israel in The Hague. “The judgment against Myanmar increases the chance that Israel will also be convicted,” they say.

The six judges in the minority found Myanmar responsible for war crimes and human rights violations but not genocide — a view that had prevailed in earlier cases such as the 2007 Bosnia ruling, where the court found the Srebrenica massacre constituted genocide but held Serbia responsible only for failing to prevent it.

The ICJ ordered Myanmar to create conditions for the safe return of the Rohingya. The ruling also arrives amid political pressure on the court: US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has threatened international courts with further sanctions if they do not comply with US wishes, and sanctions have already affected court personnel. Judges have in practice had their lives destroyed because the sanctions mean they no longer have access to American payment systems such as Visa and Mastercard, or American technology such as Microsoft. A French judge who recently visited the Norwegian Bar Association could neither book travel nor a hotel on her own because of the sanctions. Britain responded to the verdict by expelling Myanmar’s military attaché and requesting an urgent UN Security Council meeting.

At the end of a three-hour reading of the judgment at the ICJ in The Hague, Japan’s president Yuji Iwasawa declared that Myanmar had failed to prevent and punish genocide, after recounting how Myanmar’s military had exercised “extreme violence” against the predominantly Muslim Rohingya community in Rakhine State. The destruction was often followed by bulldozing and large-scale clearing of the terrain. Thereafter, a rapid development took place on the cleared areas, including security installations, new villages and houses, and other civilian infrastructure, explained judge Iwasawa.

The man considered primarily responsible for both the military operation against the Rohingya and the coup is General Min Aung Hlaing, who is now the country’s president. He and the rest of the regime are working hard to normalise relations with the outside world, not least with neighbouring countries in Southeast Asia, but after Thursday’s judgment the prospects do not look particularly bright.

Background

The South Africa case against Israel was filed in 2023 after the offensive on Gaza following Hamas’s terror attack on 7 October. The Myanmar case was filed in 2019: Gambia accused Myanmar of violating the Genocide Convention after the military offensive in Rakhine State in August 2017, where thousands were killed, villages burned and over 700,000 Rohingya driven into flight to neighbouring Bangladesh.