The Netherlands and four other European nations will establish a joint return hub in Rwanda for rejected asylum seekers.
The initiative, announced on Monday in Vienna, targets individuals who have exhausted all legal avenues for residency but refuse to leave the European Union.
A Coalition of Five Nations
The project involves the Netherlands, Germany, Austria, Greece, and Denmark. Instead of deporting migrants directly to their home countries, these governments will send them to an open-style facility in Rwanda. Nederland werkt hierbij samen met Rwanda en vier EU-landen: Duitsland, Oostenrijk, Griekenland en Denemarken.
The plan is designed for those who have completed the full asylum process and been denied legal status. “Return is an essential part of our asylum system and crucial for the support of reception,” said minister Tom Berendsen of Foreign Affairs, who represented the Netherlands at the conference. “Terugkeer is een essentieel onderdeel van ons asielsysteem en cruciaal voor draagvlak van opvang”, says minister Berendsen of Foreign Affairs.
Limited Initial Scope
The first phase will be small. Just 100 spots are expected to be available in Rwanda. Officials from the five countries project they will collectively send several dozen people to the facility starting next year. Het gaat in eerste instantie nog om kleine aantallen. Er zouden in Rwanda honderd plekken beschikbaar komen. Dat zou volgend jaar al moeten gebeuren.
To preempt legal challenges, the nations have decided to accept only single men in this initial stage. In eerste instantie willen Nederland enkel alleenstaande mannen naar Rwanda sturen, geen gezinnen dus.
/s3/static.nrc.nl/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/16140521/161126BIN_2038653207_rwanda.jpg)
Risks Severe Human Rights Violations
The proposal faces fierce criticism over the human rights situation in Rwanda. A coalition of forty organizations, including Amnesty International and Save the Children, issued a joint statement arguing the plan risks severe human rights violations against a vulnerable group. Mensenrechtenorganisaties in een verklaring. “Maar Rwanda is een land met een dictator aan de macht, en waar de mensenrechtenschendingen breed gerapporteerd zijn,” says Klaassen.
These concerns mirror past legal battles. In 2023, the British Supreme Court struck down a similar plan, ruling the human rights situation in Rwanda was too precarious for asylum transfers.
Questionable Deterrent Value
The concept of offshore processing hubs is not new. Australia used Christmas Island as a remote detention center for years before closing it in 2018 amid human rights abuse reports. “Het bekendste voorbeeld van zo’n hub is Christmas Island, voor de kust van Australië”, tells the emeritus professor. “Maar uiteindelijk zijn die kampen in 2018 gesloten vanwege grote mensenrechtenschendingen, dus dat is een mislukking geworden.”
There is little evidence such policies act as an effective deterrent, said Marlou Schrover, emeritus professor of social history at Leiden University. “There is actually no evidence for it, because 2,000 people drown in the Mediterranean Sea every year and people still keep coming,” she told reporters.
“Maar er is eigenlijk geen enkel bewijs voor (dat het werkt, red.), want er verdrinken 2.000 mensen per jaar in de Middellandse Zee en toch blijven mensen komen.”

Major Financial and Procedural Details Remain Unsettled
Major financial and procedural details remain unsettled. While the five EU countries have agreed to fund the center, the exact costs are undetermined. Rwanda has requested economic support for hosting the hub, but it is unclear if the broader EU will contribute, as several member states have objected on principle. Het gaat volgens de hoogleraar ook enorm veel geld kosten. Want het is een vrij onaantrekkelijke deal.”
Until then, the project faces review by Europe’s highest courts, which must decide if the facility complies with international human rights standards. “Er is een grote kans dat het Hof in Nederland of anders het Europees Hof voor de Rechten van de Mens hier een streep door gaat trekken, omdat de mensenrechtensituatie in Rwanda echt niet goed is,” Schrover said.
Sending Only Single Men to the Return Hub
No. In the initial phase, the participating countries will send only single men to the return hub to avoid legal complexities surrounding the right to family life.
Yes. Previous examples include the British attempt to send asylum seekers to Rwanda and the Italian government’s current efforts to establish processing centers in Albania. “Maar ook daar wordt gesproken van mensenrechtenschendingen en hebben beide hubs kritiek gekregen van zowel Italiaanse als Europese rechters,” tells the emeritus professor.
Under the plan, they would be placed in an open reception location, offered an integration program, and granted a residence permit in Rwanda. The participating countries state migrants would eventually be free to return to their countries of origin if they choose.