A Northcote shop-top apartment sold for $945,000 on Saturday, highlighting a cooling Melbourne market where buyers are increasingly hesitant to bid despite prime locations.
The property at 3/597 High Street, located on a strip named the “coolest street in the world” by Time Out in 2024, fetched $5000 below its advertised reserve of $950,000, The Age reported. The sale followed a failed auction where bidding stalled at $935,000, forcing the vendor—a long-term investor—into post-auction negotiations.
Market Uncertainty in Northcote
The apartment’s unique configuration, featuring three bedrooms and two bathrooms across two levels, drew interest from first-home buyers. Lead agent Andrew Guarino of Woodards Northcote-Thornbury described the unit as “very much a young person’s property,” noting the lack of a body corporate as a significant advantage.
Auctioneer Mario Buttera opened the bidding with an $850,000 vendor bid, according to The Age. Two first-home buyers traded increments that slowed to $1000 before the property passed in. “There was a bit of backwards and forwards, but it sold pretty much immediately,” lead agent Andrew Guarino of Woodards Northcote-Thornbury said.
Regional Auction Trends
Melbourne’s broader auction market remains under pressure, with Domain recording a preliminary clearance rate of 52 per cent from 523 reported results as of Saturday evening. This figure accounts for 105 properties that were withdrawn from sale, which are counted as unsold.
Agents attribute this sluggishness to a combination of rising interest rates, legislative changes, and the upcoming state election. In Elsternwick, a Victorian home at 21 Downshire Road sold for $1.21 million, exceeding its $1.15 million reserve despite initial fears that the property would fail to attract a single bid. Woodards Elsternwick auctioneer Sam Paynter said that while the home sold, the market is currently experiencing a period of “total uncertainty.”
Gladstone Park House Sells Above Reserve at Auction
In Gladstone Park, a three-bedroom house at 17 Vaucluse Avenue sold for $738,000 following a competitive auction between three first-home buyers. The property, which the owner renovated after purchasing it for $315,000 in 2008, had an advertised reserve of $711,000.
Ray White Sunbury agent Aaron Hill observed that buyers are frequently skipping auctions when advertised reserves appear out of reach. “It doesn’t matter what we say … they just don’t bother turning up when they see the reserve,” Hill told The Age.
Questions About Recent Auction Activity
Why are so many auctions being withdrawn?
Agents report that a mix of rate hikes, new state and federal legislative requirements, and the looming state election are cooling buyer confidence, leading to fewer successful sales.
How is the advertised reserve affecting turnout?
According to agent Aaron Hill, some potential buyers are avoiding auctions entirely if the advertised reserve price is perceived as being outside their budget, even if the final sale price eventually lands lower.
Located just 6 kilometres north-east of Melbourne’s central business district, Northcote has a history defined by the Victorian gold rush of the 1850s, when the area saw rapid development and the construction of large, expensive homes. By the 1880s, the suburb began to shift toward its long-standing reputation as a working-class community, attracting property investors and residents of more limited financial means.
The suburb is also home to rare historical landmarks, including a Carnegie library that opened in 1911 as one of only four such facilities in Australia. Additionally, the local cinema, which first opened its doors in 1912, remains one of the oldest surviving theatres in Victoria.
What happened to the High Street apartment after the auction?
The property passed in at $935,000 after the first round of bidding failed. It sold for $945,000 shortly thereafter to the underbidder, who increased his offer during post-auction negotiations.
Related reading