The New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) has commissioned an independent analysis of breath testing data following revelations that approximately 30,000 tests were “falsely or erroneously recorded.” The move comes as 130 police staff are currently under investigation nationwide.
Funding Withheld Pending Review
NZTA halted $6 million in funding to police, contingent on verification that breath test targets are being met. The agency has received weekly updates from Transport Minister Chris Bishop regarding the situation, obtained through the Official Information Act. An independent supplier has been selected to analyze the data, with a report expected early next year.
According to an October 13th update to Minister Bishop, police were unable to determine if irregular testing occurred while officers were stationary. NZTA is now encouraging police to explore methods for identifying such instances and to broaden their detection efforts.
Acting Deputy Commissioner Mike Johnson acknowledged the algorithm’s effectiveness in identifying tests conducted while in motion, but also noted limitations in detecting all forms of irregular testing, particularly in specific locations.
Future Steps and Concerns
Transport Minister Bishop described the matter as “very concerning” and emphasized the importance of a resolution. NZTA expects to verify results for the 2024/25 financial year and the first quarter of 2025/26 by early 2026. Police have stated they are working closely with NZTA to resolve the issue and are confident funding will be reinstated once data accuracy is confirmed.
Despite the ongoing investigation, police maintain they are conducting “very high levels of breath testing activity” and will continue a visible presence, particularly during the summer months.
Frequently Asked Questions
What prompted the independent analysis?
The independent analysis was commissioned by NZTA after RNZ revealed approximately 30,000 alcohol breath tests were “falsely or erroneously recorded” and 130 police staff were under investigation.
What specific issue is the algorithm designed to detect?
The algorithm identifies tests that appear to have been conducted while the testing device was in motion, specifically those taken within 90 seconds of each other with a distance indicating a speed over 20 km/h.
Is funding to police completely suspended?
NZTA has paused $6 million in funding dependent on road policing delivery, while the investigation into the breath testing data irregularities is ongoing. Funding may be authorized once data accuracy is confirmed.
How might this situation impact public trust in law enforcement and road safety initiatives?
Related reading