A Pennsylvania judge has ordered the release of body-worn camera footage related to a fatal officer-involved shooting that occurred last April. The judge determined the public has a “weighty interest” in the footage’s disclosure.
Context of the Ruling
The ruling follows a petition arguing for the footage’s release under Pennsylvania’s Act 22, a law governing public access to recordings made by law enforcement. This marks a recent success for Burke, who has previously successfully argued for the release of bodycam footage under the same law.
According to the petition, the footage relates to a confrontation between Pennsylvania State Police and Deshawn Leeth. Leeth was shot by a state trooper on the Pennsylvania turnpike after allegedly stealing a police cruiser in Ohio and driving into Pennsylvania. The Beaver County District Attorney investigated the shooting and concluded that the shooting was justified, finding no criminal violations by the officers involved.
Arguments for Release
Burke argued that the footage should be released because the District Attorney has already declined to press charges. The petition stated that the state police’s account of the shooting “leaves many important questions unanswered,” and access to the footage would provide insight into the circumstances surrounding Leeth’s death.
“Act 22 should shine a spotlight on the actions of law enforcement in Pennsylvania, but it can only do that if the law is interpreted as it was here — in favor of maximum transparency,” Burke said. “As the court’s decision confirms, the public’s interest in accessing these recordings to better understand officers’ use of deadly force outweighs the police’s interest in keeping this footage secret.”
What Happens Next
The Pennsylvania State Police has until February 5 to either turn over the requested footage or file an appeal. If the state police appeals, the case could proceed to a higher court, potentially delaying the release of the footage. If no appeal is filed, the public could have access to the bodycam footage shortly after February 5. It is also possible that the state police could release a statement regarding their decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
What prompted this legal action?
A petition argued that the public has a right to view the body-worn camera footage of the shooting under Pennsylvania’s Act 22.
What was the District Attorney’s finding in this case?
The Beaver County District Attorney investigated the shooting and concluded that the shooting was justified, determining there were no criminal violations on the part of the officers involved.
What is the deadline for the Pennsylvania State Police to respond?
The Pennsylvania State Police has until February 5 to turn over the footage or appeal the ruling.
How might increased access to bodycam footage impact public trust in law enforcement?
Related reading