Panama, Green Groups Criticise Draft as COP31 in Turkiye Stalls on Fossil Fuels

The COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkiye, has entered unscheduled overtime after nearly 200 countries failed to reach a consensus on a final deal by the Friday deadline.

Negotiators remain deadlocked primarily over the exclusion of fossil fuels from the latest draft agreement.

The current impasse follows the release of two separate draft texts. The initial version included broad commitments requested by many nations, including a goal for climate neutrality for all industrialized countries by 2030 and a work program to maintain the 1.5-degree limit, according to Greenpeace Germany head Martin Kaiser.

Environmental groups wrote in an open letter to the summit’s joint presidents, Chris Bowen and Murat Kurum, that the meeting lacked ambition to address the worsening climate crisis. “This has been the worst COP ever,” said Mohamed Adow, director of the think tank Power Shift Africa.

The removal of fossil fuel phase-out language from the Thursday draft occurred after objections from Saudi Arabia and other major oil and gas producers. This pattern mirrors tensions seen at previous summits, including COP28 in 2023.

Panama has emerged as a vocal critic of the current trajectory.

“It is not acceptable to have a COP or a cover document that does not even mention fossil fuels, and we simply will not put up with it,” Juan Carlos Navarro told a press conference.

Regenvanu also called for the removal of references to carbon capture, which he described as “false solutions” that are costly and unproven.

Consensus and the path to agreement

While the talks are strained, the definition of consensus in UN climate negotiations does not require unanimous approval from every participating nation. Official agreements have historically been “gavelled through” even when a minority of countries expressed formal objections.

Despite the friction, Australian climate minister Chris Bowen maintained that progress is still possible. “I believe the work to transition away from fossil fuels can and will continue,” Bowen said in a doorstop interview.

Fossil fuel talks deadlock pushes COP31 climate summit into overtime
Photo: Al Jazeera

Electrification target lacks renewable mandate

The draft text currently proposes an electrification target, aiming for 35 percent of global final energy consumption to come from electricity by 2035. This target has the backing of 75 countries. However, some delegations argue this target is insufficient because it does not explicitly mandate that this electricity be sourced from renewables. The European Union said that the current draft “risks turning this climate COP into a fossil summit.”

Developing nations have also expressed frustration over the lack of new finance pledges. The latest draft dropped a previously discussed $120bn target intended to assist poorer countries with climate adaptation, a move Ghana’s environment minister, Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings, called a failure to meet existing commitments. “We didn’t come here to beg,” said Agyeman-Rawlings.

Pooja Dave of Climate Action Network International added, "You made a promise, a commitment, and you are breaking that commitment." Pooja Dave stressed what the funding gap means, with Dave noting, "You cannot demand ambition from developing countries while withholding the means to deliver it."

Unresolved transition debates

Economist Mariana Mazzucato told UN News that the debate is too often reduced to finding more money, stating, “We don’t fix markets.”

Antalya, situated on Anatolia’s southwest coast and flanked by the Taurus Mountains, was founded around 200 BC as Attaleia by King Attalus II of Pergamon.

Historically a significant naval base and commercial hub for the Roman and Byzantine empires, the city has been under the control of the Seljuk and Ottoman empires. Today, it is recognized as the capital of tourism in Turkey and a pivotal part of the Turkish Riviera, drawing millions of international visitors annually.

"This Is Not Going Well": COP31 Draft Text Avoids Fossil Fuel Phaseout — Democracy Now!

As the summit extends into the weekend, observers remain focused on whether the final text will meaningfully address the climate trajectory. “Negotiators must deliver a response,” said Ani Dasgupta, president of the World Resources Institute, emphasizing that this requires going beyond slashing emissions to include scaling carbon removal. “That is really about the well-being of the people, but that is based on planetary well-being.”