Rutger McGroarty Development and NHL Readiness
McGroarty entered the organization as the clear top prospect in the Penguins’ system following an August 2024 trade that sent fellow forward prospect Brayden Yager to the Winnipeg Jets. Yet, his stock has taken a hit since joining the franchise.
His skating remains a primary concern for evaluators. According to general manager Kyle Dubas, McGroarty has actively worked to address those deficiencies. “He’s put in the work and improved on it,” Dubas said. “So we expect next year that he’ll have every opportunity to earn a spot here. How high in the lineup that is will be up to him.”
Stat Comparison: McGroarty and Horcoff Projections
- Rutger McGroarty: Age 22 | 6-1, 212 lbs | 2025-26 NHL: 24 GP, 3-3-6 | Projected Arrival: This season
- Trevor Horcoff: Age 19 | 6-5, 190 lbs | 2025-26 NCAA: 40 GP, 25-14-39 | Projected Arrival: 2028-29 season
Trevor Horcoff Michigan NCAA Trajectory
While McGroarty fights for an everyday NHL role, prospect Trevor Horcoff is building his foundation at the collegiate level. Selected with the No. 24 pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, Horcoff put together a successful sophomore season at Michigan, recording 25 goals—tied for the second-most in college hockey—alongside 14 assists for 39 points across 40 games.
That production arrived despite the 19-year-old playing through an injured right shoulder that ultimately required offseason surgery. “I was able to play through it,” Horcoff said. “It bothered me a little bit, but at the end of the day, it’s part of the game. Guys play through that stuff all the time.” Standing at 6-foot-5 and 190 pounds, the forward is expected to be ready for another potential jump as a junior at Michigan.
Evaluating Rhythm and Consistency
Pittsburgh director of player development Tom Kostopoulos pointed out consistency hurdles in the young forward’s game. “I think, at times, he lost his rhythm a little bit,” Kostopoulos said. “But that’s something that he knows, he understands and he’s working on.” Horcoff holds a projected NHL arrival timeline for the 2028-29 season.
Did you know? Trevor Horcoff’s 25 goals during his sophomore campaign at Michigan placed him tied for the second-most scores across all of college hockey, achieved while managing a shoulder injury that necessitated surgery.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is Rutger McGroarty projected to arrive full-time in the NHL?
Management projects McGroarty to earn a regular roster spot this season, following a development path that included 24 NHL games and 30 AHL games.
How was Rutger McGroarty acquired by Pittsburgh?
What were Trevor Horcoff’s stats during his sophomore NCAA season?
Horcoff recorded 25 goals and 14 assists for 39 points in 40 games for the Michigan Wolverines.
When was Trevor Horcoff drafted into the NHL?
Horcoff was selected in the first round as the No. 24 pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.
What are your expectations for Pittsburgh’s young forward group this season? Leave a comment below, explore our latest hockey prospect analysis, or subscribe to our newsletter for updates.
Related reading