Pundits Criticise VAR After Penalty Decision in NEC vs PSV

“What can you possibly do about this?”, Bram van Polen asks as he watches Deveron Fonville’s handball during the NEC – PSV match that ended 1-4, according to goal.com.

The penalty decision sparked complete disbelief when it came up on ESPN’s Goedemorgen Eredivisie. Pundits couldn’t make sense of the current handball rule after reviewing the incident involving Fonville.

“It hits the underside of his elbow, and he keeps his elbow against his body too. There’s nothing you can do about this, is there? I don’t think this is a penalty in any way,” Van Polen told goal.com.

The former PEC Zwolle defender argued that natural defensive movements make avoiding such contact nearly impossible. “When you’re moving forward in a running action, it’s very difficult to keep your arms behind your back,” he said.

Raymond van Meenen, the head of refereeing, previously explained on the same ESPN program that defenders no longer need to keep their arms behind their backs. Yet Van Polen said that controversies persist across the league, pointing to a similar incident the following week in an RKC match.

“Surely we don’t want this any more? I really thought we’d moved on from that. Since Raymond van Meenen gave that explanation, it only seems to have got worse,” Van Polen said.

Fellow pundit Hans Kraay junior agreed with the criticism of the officiating. “And Jeroen Manschot was the referee and is also the best VAR,” Kraay said.

“When he went to the screen, he could simply have said: ‘Don’t call me over for this nonsense again’,” Kraay added regarding the review process.

Van Polen offered a direct instruction for officials handling similar plays. “Just leave it alone if you’re the VAR,” he said.

Presenter Milan van Dongen also weighed in on the ongoing confusion surrounding the rule. “Hands behind your back, or not after all? We really don’t know any more,” Van Dongen said.