A rare 450-million-year-old fossil of the crinoid Dendrocrinus simcoensis, recently rediscovered in a Montreal museum collection, has provided scientists with the second-ever known example of preserved soft tissue in an ancient crinoid. According to a study published in Royal Society Open Science, the specimen’s preserved tube feet offer a rare window into how these early marine relatives of starfish navigated and fed in Paleozoic ecosystems.
How Was This Rare Fossil Discovered?
The discovery occurred not at a remote dig site, but within the drawers of a local museum in Montreal, Quebec. Lena Cole, a paleontologist at the University of Oklahoma and the study’s lead author, noted that the team identified the specimen while reviewing an existing, relatively unknown collection. According to Cole, the fossil dates back to the Paleozoic era, specifically between 541 and 252 million years ago. This makes it older than the only other previously recorded crinoid fossil containing preserved soft tissues.

Most fossils consist only of hard skeletal plates or shells because soft tissues—such as skin, organs, and eyes—decay rapidly. Finding these tissues intact is described by researchers as a “one-in-a-million” occurrence.
Why Does Soft Tissue Preservation Matter?
Soft tissue preservation allows paleontologists to reconstruct the behavior of extinct species that would otherwise remain a mystery. Because the Dendrocrinus simcoensis specimen was buried rapidly in fine, oxygen-deprived mud, minerals were able to coat and fossilize its delicate appendages. According to Cole, these feather-like tube feet were essential for the animal to navigate water currents and capture food. By comparing these features to modern crinoids, researchers can now confirm that ancient species often utilized different biological strategies to survive in their environments.
How Do Scientists Study Ancient Ecosystems?
Researchers confirm the identity of such specimens by performing a comparative analysis between the fossil’s skeletal structure and those of both extinct and living crinoids. By analyzing these morphological patterns, the team was able to “confidently” classify the fossil within its specific Paleozoic group. Cole explains that these findings help track how evolutionary patterns have shifted over hundreds of millions of years, ultimately shaping the biosphere observed today.
Pro Tips for Aspiring Paleontologists
- Check Local Collections: Many significant scientific breakthroughs occur in overlooked museum archives rather than new field excavations.
- Focus on Taphonomy: Understanding the conditions—such as rapid burial and oxygen depletion—is key to identifying where soft tissues might be preserved.
- Comparative Anatomy: Always use modern relatives as a baseline to identify variations in extinct species.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are crinoids?
- Crinoids are marine animals related to modern starfish. They have been present in Earth’s oceans for hundreds of millions of years.
- Why is soft tissue fossilization so rare?
- Soft tissues typically decompose before they can be mineralized. According to Lena Cole, it requires “unusual conditions,” such as immediate burial in fine mud to block oxygen.
- Where was the Dendrocrinus simcoensis fossil found?
- It was found in a local museum collection in Montreal, Quebec, as detailed in the study published in Royal Society Open
More on this