In a column for 1News, TVNZ Sport Presenter Scotty Stevenson argues that Cricket Australia bears responsibility for the bleeding aftermath of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal after officials shut down prospects of a new probe.
Cricket Australia Chief Executive Todd Greenberg and Interim Chair David Boon fronted the media to rule out a fresh investigation into the Australian test team’s use of sandpaper during the series against South Africa in 2018, 1News reported. Instead, the organisation announced an independent forum for players and associated tour parties to offer their version of events.
Participation in the forum will not be compulsory, and the Cricket Australia Board will decide what conclusions, if any, are released to the public by Christmas. Greenberg told reporters that seeking a “perfect truth” is futile because conflicting accounts inevitably emerge.
Another earthquake in Australian cricket with the Bancroft revelations. They have no option now but to address the issue directly. A forum to express thoughts with no further action is now untenable. This is one of Australian cricket's biggest moments and just requires them to do…
“Someone’s version of events will contradict someone else’s version of events so looking for the perfect truth doesn’t exist, and we’re not chasing that,” Greenberg said, according to 1News.
Cameron Bancroft breaks silence
Hours after the media briefing, Cameron Bancroft broke his silence in a detailed account published in The West Australian, claiming the entire team and coaching staff knew about the ball-tampering plot. Bancroft was one of three players suspended in 2018 alongside Steve Smith and David Warner.
The article by Bancroft on @cricinfo reveals what many of us have insisted post Khwaja's book release: @patcummins30 has been lying repeatedly. He is NOT a leader! After throwing teammates under the bus twice before, he did it again in the press conference a few days back. Not…
Bancroft wrote that he withheld important details during the initial four-day review conducted in 2018 by Executive General Manager of Team Performance Pat Howard and Senior Legal Counsel and Head of Integrity Iain Roy in order to protect Cricket Australia’s investigation. His recent intervention followed a lengthy press conference by current Test captain Pat Cummins, who dismissed allegations in Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr, as “complete and utter nonsense”.
“What I saw, experienced and lived with, not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa, is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time,” Bancroft wrote, as reported by the NZ Herald.
Corroborating accounts and dissent
Bancroft’s claims received backing from several figures connected to the 2018 tour. Former 12th man Chadd Sayers told Australian radio station SEN that he believes everyone in the side knew what was happening, noting that the team discussed the issue in the changing rooms for up to 90 minutes after play in Cape Town, according to the BBC.
Former spinner Greg Holland told The Australian that players sat as a group at the hotel to discuss who would take the blame. Meanwhile, RNZ reported that former media manager Kate Hutchison objected to the ball-tampering at the time, walking away from the discussion and earning praise from Bancroft for being the sole dissenting voice.
In response to the mounting pressure, Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Nathan Lyon publicly maintained their denials of prior awareness. Starc reiterated that stance, stating, “I’ll stick to what I said five years ago … We weren’t aware of anything being taken onto the field,” as noted by The Independent.
“it's almost like we're back in 2018. This was buried in a shallow grave and eight years later we're starting to find out the truth, and it's a lot worse than we thought.” veteran Australian cricket journalist Peter Lalor told ABC News Breakfast.
Frequently asked questions about the inquiry
Will Cricket Australia make the forum findings public?
The Cricket Australia Board retains final discretion over what conclusions from the independent forum are released to the public. Retired batsman Usman Khawaja questioned this structure, asking how an internal board decision on disclosure constitutes a transparent presentation of participant accounts.
Cricket Australia traces its origins to the Australian Board of Control for International Cricket, formed in 1905 after early tours were privately organised and funded. The body was incorporated as a company limited by guarantee in 1982.
It operates the men’s national team, which played in the first-ever Test match against England in 1877, and the women’s team, which played its first Women’s Test against England in 1934. The organisation is governed by nine independent directors and comprises six state member associations.
When will Australia play next?
Australia is currently hosting England in a one-day international series and is scheduled to play New Zealand in a three-Test series starting on 9 December in Perth, according to RNZ.
Pat Cummins' camp say his position "hasn't changed" after Cameron Bancroft's fresh Sandpapergate revelations 🤨 pic.twitter.com/lVXXymlolB
More on Test
Keep reading