Daisy Edgar-Jones and Esmé Creed-Miles star as the Dashwood sisters in a moody, naturalistic feature film adaptation of Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility, directed by Georgia Oakley and scripted by Diana Reid. The production shifts the classic romance toward an austere, sober-minded study of women’s economic insecurity, marking the first feature film adaptation of the novel since Ang Lee’s 1995 film.
A Naturalistic and Moody Austen Adaptation
Director Georgia Oakley follows up her BAFTA-winning debut Blue Jean with a rural, tactile vision of late 18th-century England. The film captures the physical grit of multi-day carriage journeys and the natural splendor of quivering cattails and dew-spotted spiders on 35mm film stock. However, the mood remains cooler and more downbeat than the 1995 Emma Thompson and Ang Lee version, avoiding a sugar-rush final wedding scene in favor of cloudier weather and ruminative pacing.
Financial Insecurity and Family Eviction
The core plot kicks off when Mrs. Dashwood, played by Caitríona Balfe, finds herself penniless after her husband’s estate goes entirely to male heir John Dashwood (Tom Brooke). The script by Diana Reid puts sharper focus on Mrs. Dashwood’s deliberate decision to move her daughters away to the West Country to avoid the indignity of gold-digger labels, leaving their stately Sussex home for a modest cottage in Devon.
Did you know? In a visual role-reversal during their early scenes together, it is Elinor (Daisy Edgar-Jones) who draws a portrait of Edward Ferrars (George MacKay).
Romance, Cast Dynamics, and Divergent Sisters
Elinor’s steady romance with the shy and principled Edward Ferrars (George MacKay) contrasts sharply with Marianne’s impulsive attachment to the charming yet slippery John Willoughby, played by Frank Dillane. Dillane imbues Willoughby with an insidious charm and a Uriah Heep smirk. Meanwhile, Herbert Nordrum portrays the loyal Colonel Brandon, though critics note his performance leans stolid and eccentric. Fiona Shaw steals scenes as the gossipy, forthright Mrs. Jennings, injecting high energy whenever she appears on screen alongside the cast.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who directs the new adaptation of Sense and Sensibility?
Georgia Oakley directs the film, following her 2022 breakout drama Blue Jean.
Who plays the Dashwood sisters?
Daisy Edgar-Jones stars as the reserved Elinor, and Esmé Creed-Miles plays the passionate Marianne.
How does this version compare to the 1995 film?
According to film critics, the new adaptation offers a cooler, more austere, and naturalistic tone compared to Ang Lee’s 1995 movie, dropping the upbeat wedding finale for a sober exploration of economic precarity.
When is the film released?
The film releases on September 25 in the UK, October 15 in Australia, and October 16 in the US.
Join the Conversation
What is your favorite Jane Austen screen adaptation of all time? Share your thoughts in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest film reviews and entertainment updates.