Sodium Valproate Scandal: Confirmed Impact on Families

Sodium valproate exposes babies in the womb to a 10% chance of physical abnormalities and a 40% chance of cognitive problems, according to reporting by bbc.com.

Emma Friedmann’s son Andrew is one of an estimated 20,000 children in the UK believed to have been harmed by the epilepsy drug since its introduction in the 1970s. The 28-year-old from Leicester has severe autism and learning disabilities, and he will never live independently.

“He will never achieve full mental capacity and he needs 24/7 support,” Emma Friedmann told BBC. “What happens when I die? Where will he live? Who will manage his wellbeing, finances, education, employment and recreation?”

“Even though I know it’s not my fault, the guilt continues and I don’t think it will ever go away,” Emma Friedmann said.

Two mothers started the sodium valproate campaign

The sodium valproate scandal was uncovered thanks to a campaign started 17 years ago by two mothers who suspected a specific cause for their children’s disabilities, The Guardian reported.

Janet Williams began researching at Manchester Central library when doctors could not answer her questions about her sons’ developmental delays. Emma Murphy from Bury later joined the effort after five of her six children experienced similar difficulties following exposure to Epilim, The Guardian noted.

Emma Friedmann has black hair and is wearing a red dress
Photo: BBC

The campaign faced early skepticism from a male-dominated audience that dismissed anecdotal data. Professor David Chadwick later encouraged a formal study, which helped determine that the drug carries a 10% risk of physical malformations and a 30% to 40% risk of serious neurodevelopmental disorders, The Guardian reported. During subsequent meetings in Westminster, campaigners were referred to as “bored, hysterical housewives,” according to Emma Murphy cited by The Guardian.

Rosemary Nayler from Evesham said that doctors repeatedly urged her to keep taking the tablets and increased her dose when she became pregnant with her daughter Nadia Williams at age 34, JournalArta Global reported. When asked if the medication could affect the fetus, doctors told her there was no effect on children, according to JournalArta Global. Nadia Williams is now 37, registered blind and deaf, autistic, and living with mobility issues.

Rosemary Nayler, 72, is among parents urging the government to “admit where they’ve gone wrong.”

Calls for Government Redress and Response

A government-commissioned 2020 Cumberlege Report found that families did not receive information about treatment risks during pregnancy, preventing informed choices and causing lifelong impacts, bbc.com reported. A further report published in 2024 by Patient Safety Commissioner Dr Henrietta Hughes said that the case for redress is clear and must span financial and non-financial aspects.

Mums Expose Sodium Valproate Scandal — Newsreel

Health ministers in Northern Ireland, Wales, and Scotland called on the UK government to provide certainty to victims in a joint letter to UK Public Health and Patient Safety Minister Dame Diana Johnson, Irish Legal News reported.

The 2024 report by Dr Henrietta Hughes has not yet received a formal response from the UK government, according to Irish Legal News.

Northern Ireland Minister for Health Robbie Butler said that affected families have waited too long for a formal response and certainty. Butler said that because the regulation of medicines and medical devices sits with Westminster, none of the devolved administrations can move forward until the UK government responds.

Sodium Valproate Scandal: Confirmed Impact on Families
Photo: The Guardian

Common Questions About Sodium Valproate

When were warnings added to valproate pill packets?

In 2016, alerts regarding the potential dangers the medication posed to unborn children were placed onto the exterior of valproate packaging, as reported by the BBC.

What does current MHRA guidance state?

The latest guidance from the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency states that valproate must not be prescribed to any woman or girl able to have children unless the conditions of the pregnancy prevention programme are followed, bbc.com reported.

What pilot services are currently operating?

Hospital facilities in Newcastle and Manchester hosted a pilot initiative designed for individuals who had encountered pharmaceuticals while in utero, offering diagnostic evaluations, health assessments, and care strategies, according to JournalArta Global.

Listen to BBC Leicester on social media

Conservatives and Labour have both agreed its successive government failures. “That’s why redress matters so much,” Emma Friedmann said. Listen to BBC Radio Leicester on Sounds and follow BBC Leicester on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram.