Despite widespread clinical awareness that broad immunoglobulin E blood tests frequently produce false-positive results, healthcare providers continue ordering the panels for unverified conditions such as eczema and hives, according to research presented at the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology annual meeting.
Why Do Doctors Order Flawed Tests?
Eighty-five percent of surveyed clinicians recognize that broad food allergy panels carry high false-positive rates, yet many still request them, Medscape reported. Researchers surveyed 300 clinicians who ordered at least one panel in 2024 at their institution, with 43 completing the anonymous questionnaire. Most respondents were physicians, nurse practitioners, or physician assistants working in general internal medicine and pediatrics.
“Most of the clinicians we surveyed already knew these tests could lead to false positive results, but many still ordered them despite current guidelines advising against their use,” said Katelyn Wong, MD, allergist-immunologist and senior author of the study, in a release covered by Clinical Lab Products.
When asked about appropriate indications, respondents pointed to IgE-mediated food allergies, urticaria, and eczema. Actual ordering habits mirrored this confusion, as 21% of providers requested the blood tests simply in response to direct patient or family pressure. At one hospital system alone, staff ordered more than 1,700 broad panels in a single year.
How Training Divides Clinical Practice
Professional background shapes how clinicians evaluate skin conditions and family history. When presented with a clinical scenario involving a patient with eczema and a family history of food allergies, 63% of nurse practitioners and physician assistants agreed that a broad panel was indicated.
Only 30% of physicians agreed with that approach, according to data highlighted by [Respiratory Therapy]. Broad panels simultaneously measure antibodies to multiple foods, flagging sensitization rather than an actual clinical reaction. Experts recommend starting with a detailed clinical history rather than defaulting to broad blood work.
What Are the Risks of Unnecessary Avoidance?
False-positive results trigger cascading consequences for families and healthcare systems alike. “False-positive results can lead families to cut out foods that were never actually unsafe, cause unnecessary stress, and add extra costs,” Katelyn Wong, MD, allergist-immunologist and senior author of the study, told Medscape.
“Avoidance of multiple foods may also lead to nutritional deficiencies, reduced quality of life for patients and families, and increased family stress,” Wong told Medscape.
Some highly atopic patients completely lose their ability to tolerate a food after prolonged avoidance, occasionally developing a true allergy as a direct result.

“I have seen a lot of patients who avoid a food because their understanding was that they are allergic [on the basis] of a food allergy test,” Aarti Pandya, MD, medical director of the Food Allergy Center at Children's Mercy in Kansas City, Missouri, said.
What a positive food allergy panel result means
What does a positive result on a broad food allergy panel actually mean?
A positive result indicates that a patient’s immune system has produced IgE antibodies showing sensitization to a specific food. It does not necessarily mean the patient will experience an actual allergic reaction when eating that food.
Who was surveyed in the new research?
Researchers contacted 300 clinicians who had ordered at least one broad food allergy panel in 2024, resulting in 43 completed responses from physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants, as reported by [News-Medical].

When should targeted testing be used instead?
Targeted testing is appropriate when a patient’s clinical history points to an immediate, specific reaction after eating a particular food, followed by consultation with a board-certified allergist.
“Primary care clinicians should first take a careful history to discern what symptoms were noted after eating a food,” Katelyn Wong, MD, allergist-immunologist and senior author of the study, said.
Where was the study presented?
The findings were presented at the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology Annual Scientific Meeting, which runs from November 12 through November 16, as noted by [Newswise].
Worth a look