Sotheby’s proceeds with Van Gogh sale, heirs claim ‘duress

Sotheby’s auction house confirmed it will proceed with the $180 million sale of a Vincent van Gogh painting on Wednesday, despite a last-minute restitution claim from the descendants of its former owner.

The heirs of Samuel Fischer, a Jewish publisher who lived in Berlin before World War II, argue that the work, Châtaigniers en fleurs (“Blossoming Chestnut Trees”), was sold under duress due to Nazi persecution, cnn.com reported.

The painting, an 1890 masterpiece, is the centerpiece of the auction house’s sale of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection. While the auction will move forward as planned, Sotheby’s stated it is “aware of the concerns” and has been “in dialogue” with the Fischer heirs, cnn.com reported.

Sotheby's $180M Van Gogh Auction Faces Nazi-Era Dispute — News To Like

The 1936 Sale Dispute

Gunnar Schnabel, a Berlin-based lawyer representing the unnamed US-based heirs, urged the auction house to prove that the painting was sold at market value and that the family would have proceeded with the sale “even without Nazi rule,” The New York Times reported.

Schnabel contends that the family business faced financial collapse specifically because the Nazi regime blacklisted authors like Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse, forcing the family to pay the “Reich flight tax” as they fled Germany, according to The New York Times.

Sotheby’s maintains there is no evidence of a forced sale. The auction house said that the 1936 transaction, conducted in the Netherlands, was completed for 68,000 Swiss francs, which it describes as a strong price for the era, ARTnews.com reported. Luke Nikas, a lawyer for the auction house, said that the family successfully recovered other works after the war but never pursued this specific Van Gogh, ARTnews.com reported.

Vincent van Gogh’s “Châtaigniers en Fleurs” was set to be the centerpiece of Sotheby’s auction next week
Photo: The New York Times

Washington Principles Influence How Owners Handle Restitution Claims

The dispute invokes the 1998 Washington Principles, which provide a framework for resolving claims regarding Nazi-era assets. Although these guidelines are non-binding, they have increasingly influenced how auction houses handle provenance, cnn.com reported.

In a statement provided via Sotheby’s, the current owners, the Blaquier-Arrieta family, said they recognize the “historical sensitivities involved” and support “constructive dialogue” regarding the claim, cnn.com reported. The collection itself has faced separate scrutiny, as the late Carlos Pedro Blaquier was previously accused of involvement in the forced detention of workers during Argentina’s military dictatorship, The Guardian reported.

Sotheby's auction of $180m Van Gogh challenged over claims it was 'sold under duress' — DR JAMES VOND INT'L

Questions About the Fischer Painting and the HEAR Act

Samuel Fischer deposited the painting at the Paul Cassirer & Co. gallery in Amsterdam around 1932 or 1933. His heirs, Brigitte and Gottfried Bermann-Fischer, arranged for the sale to French collectors in 1936 while they were living in Vienna after fleeing Berlin, cnn.com reported.

Does the HEAR Act change the legal standing of this claim?
The Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery (HEAR) Act eliminated the "laches" defense, which previously allowed institutions to dismiss claims based on long delays in filing, ARTnews.com reported. However, the law does not change the legal definition of what constitutes a forced sale under duress.

Van Gogh Sale Proceeds Despite Nazi-Era Duress Claim
Photo: The Guardian

The painting is backed by a financial guarantee from Sotheby’s, ensuring the seller a minimum price regardless of the outcome, The New York Times reported. Whether a settlement between the heirs and the current owners will be reached before the auction remains to be seen, ARTnews.com reported.