South Korea Faces Backlash Over New Nuclear Plant Public Consultation Plans

The government has decided to submit the construction of new nuclear power plants to a public debate process to address rising electricity demand driven by three major projects, according to the Climate, Energy and Environment Ministry. The upcoming three-month public deliberation will evaluate power demand alongside the economic and safety aspects of nuclear energy to determine what role reactors will play in future power supplies. Critics argue the process risks becoming a pre-determined formality because the administration has repeatedly emphasized the necessity of new atomic facilities.

Nuclear Deliberation Committee Structure and Schedule

The Climate, Energy and Environment Ministry reported the nuclear public debate plan during a cabinet meeting held on the morning of October 22. To oversee the proceedings, the government will form a “Nuclear Public Deliberation Committee for the Basic Plan on Electricity Supply and Demand” consisting of no more than 11 members, including one chairperson. Government explanations indicate that candidates will be recommended by organizations and groups across the humanities and social sciences, science and technology, survey statistics, conflict management, and energy sectors, ensuring that chosen members have no direct conflict of interest with nuclear power. A separate specialist committee will provide technical information regarding power demand and nuclear systems.

According to the ministry’s timeline, the public deliberation will utilize a representative citizen participation group for structured discussions and debates. Expert public hearings and online public opinion collection will run concurrently with these sessions. The deliberation committee will synthesize these findings to issue a recommendation to the government around December. Consequently, the government has delayed the finalization of the 12th Basic Plan on Electricity Supply and Demand—originally scheduled for October—until after the conclusion of the public deliberation process.

Did You Know? Large-scale public deliberations regarding nuclear power in the country previously occurred in 2017 during the first year of Moon Jae-in’s administration, when a citizen participation group deliberated for three months over the construction of the Shin-Kori units 5 and 6 and ultimately recommended resuming construction with 59.5% support.

Government Position and Scope of the Review

During an afternoon briefing on October 22, Climate, Energy and Environment Minister Kim Sung-hwan stated that recent polls show high approval for nuclear power, noting that if the process merely asked a binary yes-or-no question, a separate public debate would be unnecessary. Minister Kim explained that the deliberation committee will not determine the exact scale of new nuclear construction, and that detailed facility plans will be finalized later by the electricity plan committee and the ministry. He added that already approved nuclear projects and applications for design life extensions will remain unaffected by the current public debate.

The 2017 precedent saw the government accept the deliberation committee’s recommendation to restart the suspended Shin-Kori units 5 and 6 after a 59.5% majority voted in favor of construction, contrasting with a 40.5% opposition rate. Officials maintain that the present initiative focuses on establishing the broader strategic role of atomic energy within the national supply framework rather than revisiting past construction decisions.

Criticism From Climate and Civil Organizations

Climate and environmental organizations have challenged the fairness of the initiative, arguing that the Lee Jae-myung administration has already signaled its intent to expand nuclear power. Lee Hun-seok, a policy committee member at Energy Justice Actions, stated during a 12th electricity plan debate that the climate minister effectively treated large-scale reactors and small modular reactors as predetermined outcomes. According to Lee, using a public consultation merely to build consensus for pre-decided policy directions contradicts the fundamental purpose of public deliberation.

S. Korea to build two new nuclear power plants by 2038 under 11th power supply plan

Additional concerns focus on the information supplied to the citizen participation group. Lim Jae-min, secretary general of the Energy Transition Forum, pointed out that framing the debate around the difficulty of meeting rising electricity demand through renewables alone will predictably steer participants toward endorsing nuclear options. Yoo Esther, an executive committee member of the National Action for Stopping New Nuclear Power Plants and a Nuclear-Free Society, cautioned that atomic infrastructure decisions lock in operational paths for roughly 70 years. Yoo argued that the administration should instead center energy policies around renewable sources and reassess the projected demand figures outlined in the 12th electricity plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the purpose of the newly announced public deliberation?
The three-month deliberation evaluates power demand and the economic and safety aspects of nuclear energy to determine what role reactors will play in future electricity supplies.

South Korea Faces Backlash Over New Nuclear Plant Public Consultation Plans

Who will oversee the public debate process?
An 11-member committee, including one chairperson, will lead the process, drawing from non-conflicted candidates recommended by organizations across the humanities, sciences, statistics, conflict management, and energy sectors.

How will the public deliberation results be implemented?
The deliberation committee will submit a recommendation to the government around December, and the findings will be incorporated into the 12th Basic Plan on Electricity Supply and Demand.

How do you view the balance between public deliberation and government policy goals in shaping national energy infrastructure?

Why Korea's nuclear power plans are back on – and the rest of the world could benefit!

Leave a Comment