Andrea Mary Marshall, the 44-year-old owner of the fashion brand Salon 1884, was arraigned in Manhattan Supreme Court on Wednesday on charges of grand larceny and scheme to defraud. Prosecutors allege Marshall withheld over $54,000 in wages from nine employees, subjecting them to 17-hour workdays and sweatshop conditions in the Garment District between August 2023 and June 2026. Marshall has pleaded not guilty.
The Allegations Against Salon 1884
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg stated that Marshall exploited a power imbalance with workers on W. 39th St. who were dependent on their wages for basic living expenses. According to the indictment, Marshall maintained direct control over scheduling and pay, forcing employees to work over 40 hours weekly, with some individuals clocking more than 100 hours. The charging papers include text messages from seamstresses pleading for payment to support their families, including one worker asking for funds to send to her children in Ecuador.

Did You Know? Despite marketing her brand as “responsibly made” and focused on “sustainable practice,” prosecutors allege Marshall frequently paid workers in cash, checks, or even clothing rather than consistent wages.
Industry Context and Brand Reputation
Salon 1884 launched in 2021 and established retail partnerships with Neiman Marcus, Net-A-Porter, and Moda Operandi. While the brand’s website highlights its manufacturing in New York City’s Garment Center and environmentally conscious materials, prosecutors contend the business was sustained through the illegal exploitation of labor. The brand has gained visibility through features in publications like Vogue, Forbes, and Women’s Wear Daily, and has been worn by public figures including Julia Roberts and Cynthia Erivo.
Legal Consequences and Ongoing Investigation
Marshall faces charges related to wage theft and the failure to carry required workers’ compensation insurance. New York Labor Commissioner Roberta Reardon noted that the case serves as a reminder that wage theft is a criminal act. If convicted, Marshall could face a prison sentence ranging from five to 15 years. The Manhattan District Attorney’s office has stated the investigation remains active and has encouraged other potential victims to contact their worker protection unit, noting that inquiries regarding immigration status will not be part of the process.
Expert Insight: The divergence between the brand’s public-facing “sustainable” marketing and the alleged working conditions highlights a significant challenge in modern fashion retail. When luxury branding relies on a narrative of ethical craftsmanship, the failure to provide basic legal protections for the workforce creates not only a human rights issue but a massive liability for both the owner and the retail platforms that distribute the product.
Frequently Asked Questions
What charges does Andrea Mary Marshall face?
Marshall is charged with grand larceny, scheme to defraud, and related offenses for allegedly stealing over $54,000 in wages and failing to carry mandatory workers’ compensation insurance.
How many employees were affected by the alleged wage theft?
According to the Manhattan District Attorney’s office, nine employees were identified as victims of the alleged exploitation.
What is the potential prison time for these offenses?
If convicted, Marshall could face between five and 15 years in prison.
How should luxury consumers hold brands accountable when their marketing claims contradict their labor practices?











