The NYPD has released body-camera footage documenting a police-involved shooting in East Harlem earlier this month. The video shows an officer firing a single shot at a man wielding a 13-inch knife who charged toward him.
The incident occurred on April 6 around 1:38 a.m. Footage of the incident shows 53-year-old Carlos Santiago being shot once in the abdomen by Officer Maxwell Bindman.
According to the recording, Bindman ordered Santiago to “Drop the knife!” four times. The shooting occurred after Santiago refused the orders and ran directly toward the officer.
Timeline of the Escalation
The confrontation began approximately 20 minutes before the shooting, around 1:15 a.m. Santiago engaged in an argument with workers inside the City Fresh Market on Third Ave. Near E. 120th St.
Store security removed Santiago after he refused to leave the premises. However, he returned shortly after, waving a knife and threatening employees for several minutes.
NYPD Inspector Andrew Natiw stated that Santiago became “irate and disorderly,” eventually banging the knife against the store’s exterior glass. Store workers locked the doors and contacted 911.
Legal and Medical Aftermath
Following the shooting, Santiago was rushed to Harlem Hospital. He underwent surgery and was reported to be in critical but stable condition. The officer fired a single shot to stop the advance.
Officer Bindman and another officer on the scene were taken to a hospital for observation, though neither was injured. Santiago has since been charged with criminal possession of a weapon and menacing a police officer.
At his Manhattan Criminal Court arraignment on April 9, bail was set at $5,000 cash and a $10,000 bond. Santiago is scheduled to return to court on May 13.
Defendant History
Police records indicate that Santiago has been arrested six times in the past. His prior charges include burglary, felony assault, criminal contempt, and the criminal sale and possession of controlled substances.
Inspector Natiw noted that it remains unclear what sparked the original argument with store workers or if the suspect is experiencing mental health issues.
Frequently Asked Questions
What caused the encounter between Carlos Santiago and the NYPD?
The encounter followed a dispute at a City Fresh Market where Santiago was removed by security. He returned with a 13-inch kitchen knife, threatened workers, and eventually charged at Officer Maxwell Bindman after ignoring multiple commands to drop the weapon.
What are the current charges against Carlos Santiago?
Santiago has been charged with criminal possession of a weapon and menacing a police officer.
Were any officers injured during the incident?
No. While Officer Bindman and another responding officer were taken to a hospital for observation, they were not hurt.
How should cities balance the need for immediate police intervention with the management of potential mental health crises during public disputes?
