The Pittsburgh Steelers’ selection of Penn State quarterback Drew Allar in the third round of the 2026 NFL Draft represents a high-upside gamble on physical traits under the guidance of head coach Mike McCarthy. While analysts originally questioned the draft slot, internal data and team fit suggest Allar could become a value-driven asset if he successfully develops his mechanics and decision-making behind veterans like Aaron Rodgers.
Why Analysts Are Reevaluating the Drew Allar Pick
While initial reactions to the 76th overall pick were skeptical, observers are finding reasons to believe Allar could outperform his draft position. CBS Sports analyst Ryan Wilson noted that while he initially assigned Allar a fifth-round grade due to inconsistent footwork and pressure-induced errors, the situation in Pittsburgh changes the calculus. According to Wilson, the Steelers provide a "quarterback-friendly" environment for a rookie, as McCarthy has a proven track record of developing passers who can create plays outside of structure.
The Challenge of Allar’s Development
Allar’s profile is defined by a sharp contrast between his physical gifts and his collegiate consistency. As a former 5-star recruit, he possesses elite arm strength and size, yet he struggled with turnover-prone stretches at Penn State. Notable instances include a backbreaking interception against Notre Dame in the 2024 College Football Playoff semifinals and a game-ending turnover against Oregon in 2025. Following that 2025 season, Allar suffered a broken ankle, and the Penn State coaching staff—including interim coach Terry Smith—acknowledged that the team’s offensive scheme did not consistently align with Allar’s specific strengths as a pro-style quarterback.
Did you know?
Drew Allar’s transition to the NFL is being compared to other high-profile prospects, with analysts highlighting his need to play in a structured, pro-style offense to unlock his potential.
What Success Looks Like for the Steelers
The Steelers’ primary goal for 2026 is for Allar to serve as the QB3, focusing on learning and adjusting to the speed of the NFL. Wilson emphasizes that if the team can cultivate the version of Allar that "trusts his eyes, plays on time and takes the easy completions," the selection could be viewed as one of the best fits in the 2026 class. Conversely, if old habits persist, the learning curve may prove steeper than expected, potentially validating the early criticism that the team reached for him in the third round.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Steelers draft Drew Allar?
The team views Allar as a long-term developmental prospect. Head coach Mike McCarthy specifically sought out his high-end physical traits, aiming to refine his mechanics and decision-making within a pro-style system.
What are the primary concerns regarding Allar’s game?
According to analysis from CBS Sports, Allar has struggled with hurried footwork and consistency under pressure. His collegiate career included several high-profile interceptions at critical moments during his time at Penn State.
Is Allar expected to start in 2026?
No. The current expectation is that Allar will serve as the third-string quarterback behind Aaron Rodgers and either Mason Rudolph or Will Howard, allowing him time to develop away from the pressure of immediate starting duties.
Pro Tip: Keep an eye on how Allar’s footwork evolves during his first training camp. Experts suggest that his ability to "play on time" is the single most important indicator of whether he will meet his franchise-quarterback potential.
What are your thoughts on the Steelers’ quarterback room for the upcoming season? Join the conversation in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for more deep dives into the 2026 draft class.