Set in Yorkshire, England, two years into World War I, “The Choral” depicts a community grappling with loss and finding solace in song. The film, lauded for its period detail and script by Alan Bennett, centers on a local choral society struggling to maintain its ranks as young men are drawn into the conflict.
A Town’s Struggle for Harmony
Alderman Bernard Duxbury (Roger Allam), owner of the local mill and head of the choral society, is determined to keep the music alive, even as the war drains the town of male voices under the age of 18. His search for a new choirmaster leads him to Dr. Henry Guthrie (Ralph Fiennes), a conductor with a past conducting stint in Germany, and a reputation that raises eyebrows among the townspeople due to his atheism and unclear personal life. As Duxbury admits, he “would prefer a family man.”
Despite initial reservations, Duxbury supports Guthrie, recognizing his artistic talent. The film emphasizes that music-making, even in its most “amateurish and compromised” form, offers a vital source of hope. This sentiment even impacts Guthrie, whose cynicism is lessened by the power of collective song.
Community in Crisis
The lives of several town residents are interwoven throughout the narrative. Lofty (Oliver Briscombe) delivers devastating news via war department telegrams, while his friend Ellis (Taylor Uttley) displays callous disregard for the grief of others. Mary (Amara Okereke), a Salvation Army trooper, is celebrated for her angelic voice. Bella (Emily Fairn) awaits news of her soldier beau, Clyde (Jacob Dudman), who returns having lost an arm in combat, a reunion that is far from idyllic.
Jacob, a former choir member, initially refuses to rejoin after witnessing the horrors of the trenches. Guthrie persuades him to return, arguing that his experiences offer a unique perspective to pour into his singing. This scene, and Jacob’s subsequent sharing of battlefield realities with the choir, is presented as the film’s emotional core.
A Composer’s Displeasure
The film reaches a comedic peak with the arrival of Sir Edward Elgar (Simon Russell Beale), whose oratorio “The Dream of Gerontius” is adapted by the choir. Guthrie’s revision, casting a soldier as Gerontius, provokes Elgar’s outrage and a temporary withdrawal of permission to perform. Despite this setback, the community rallies, recognizing the deeper significance of their musical endeavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the central theme of “The Choral”?
The film explores how music-making provides spiritual sustenance and a sense of community, particularly during times of hardship like World War I.
Who are some of the key characters in the film?
Key characters include Alderman Bernard Duxbury, Dr. Henry Guthrie, Lofty, Ellis, Mary, Bella, and Clyde, each representing different facets of the town’s experience during the war.
What role does Sir Edward Elgar play in the story?
Sir Edward Elgar’s arrival and reaction to the choir’s adaptation of his oratorio provide a comedic element, but also underscore the community’s determination to find meaning through music.
How do you think communities find strength and purpose during times of widespread conflict?
Worth a look