The United States government has criticized Australia’s proposal to give users the ability to opt out of social media algorithms, warning that the measures risk facilitating viewpoint-based censorship. Under draft Digital Duty of Care legislation introduced by Australia’s center-left Labor government, tech firms would face substantial fines for failing to give users options to turn off algorithmic recommendation feeds.
US Criticism of Proposed Australian Algorithm Laws
In a formal submission during Australia’s public consultation process, the US Embassy in Canberra stated that Washington had serious concerns about the legislation. The submission warned that allowing the government to enforce vague definitions of harm could lead to protected speech being suppressed. According to the US statement, if companies are compelled to aggressively filter content to avoid regulatory penalties, the suppression of a disfavored speaker or media source would be indistinguishable from outright removal.
Global Repercussions and Independent Voice Concerns
The US submission cautioned that mandated platform design features could impact users beyond Australia’s borders. By forcing platforms to adopt rigid, one-size-fits-all requirements, the rules could influence what users see, say, and hear globally. Washington specifically warned that the rules might reduce the reach of independent journalists and other voices covering sensitive or controversial topics if platforms feel pressured to pre-emptively demote them.
Additionally, the US called on Canberra to ensure that the biases and preferences of government officials do not disadvantage minority-viewpoint speech, while expressing worry that the regulations could affect Australia’s reputation as an innovation-friendly jurisdiction.
Australian Government Response and Penalties
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese defended the policy while speaking to the media in New York during a visit to the United Nations General Assembly. Rejecting claims of government overreach, Albanese stated that the legislation is not about giving government control, but about giving people back control over what appears on their devices.

Under the proposed Digital Duty of Care legislation, platforms would be required to notify new and existing users, offering them a choice over their default feeds. Users over the age of 16 could opt in to personalized algorithmic recommendations or choose to view content solely from friends and creators they follow. Companies that fail to comply face penalties as high as 109.2 million Australian dollars ($78.6 million).
Context of Australian Online Safety Reforms
The proposed digital duty of care framework builds upon previous regulatory actions by Canberra. Last December, Australia introduced a world-first ban preventing children under 16 from holding accounts on major social media platforms such as Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok. The broader safety agenda also aims to shield minors from online harms including eating disorders, hostile ideas about women, pornography, crime, and dangerous stunts.

While the Australian opposition indicated it had not yet seen the bill and remained skeptical of potential censorship, the government continues to gather feedback from digital platforms, industry bodies, civil society organizations, and advocates before pushing the legislation through Parliament.
Related reading