“The criminal justice system can turn on a whim,” said Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly was murdered in 1993, following a petition filed Monday by family members of murder victims to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s mass commutation of California’s Death Row.
The legal action, brought by more than two dozen family members along with a coalition of prosecutors and crime victims’ advocates, challenges the governor’s November 5 announcement to commute the sentences of all 548 people currently facing execution in the state. According to the petition, the governor failed to provide the required legal notice to victims before moving to convert these sentences to life in prison.
“Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process, followed and applied the law,” the petition says, filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, argues that Newsom's decision represents an abuse of power that overrides the judgments rendered by jurors and judges.
The petitioners are requesting that the state Supreme Court block the mass commutation to allow for individual review of each of the 548 death sentences. The group further alleges the mass commutations were made without mandated “individualized consideration of the intended recipients.”
Legal Hurdles for Mass Commutation
The governor’s proposal faces a complex procedural path under the California Constitution. While Newsom may unilaterally commute the sentences of prisoners convicted of a single felony, the state Supreme Court must affirm any commutation for inmates with multiple felony convictions. For those who do not have a separate felony conviction, the Governor can unilaterally commute their sentence.
According to the Habeas Corpus Resource Center, this requirement applies to approximately 70% of California’s condemned inmates. The governor has submitted a list of 382 prisoners with multiple convictions to the state Supreme Court for their recommendation, a step the court has previously described as a check on executive power.

Did You Know? California has not carried out an execution in 20 years. The state’s last execution took place on January 17, 2006, when Clarence Ray Allen was put to death by lethal injection.
Diverging Views on Capital Punishment
The governor’s move has drawn sharp criticism from victims’ families who feel their input was bypassed. In his open letter regarding the decision, Newsom labeled the state’s system for administering the death penalty “a failure” and said that he reached a personal conclusion that “the state cannot morally kill” those who commit brutal crimes.
“But as Governor, I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them,” Newsom wrote in an open letter announcing his decision.
Conversely, some prosecutors and advocates have publicly supported the governor’s action. Santa Clara County District Attorney Jeff Rosen said that he believes the state will remain safer by moving away from what he described as “outdated and ineffective practices.” The ACLU and other death penalty opponents also applauded the move, citing the risk of executing innocent people.
This case asks the California Supreme Court to determine whether Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute the sentences of all death row inmates complies with state law regarding executive clemency.
Procedural Uncertainty
Legal observers note that the lack of history regarding such a broad clemency order complicates the court’s review. Newsom’s commutation plan involves 529 men and 19 women.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does the governor need Supreme Court approval for some inmates?
Under the California Constitution, the Supreme Court must provide a recommendation to the governor for any commutation involving a felon with more than one felony conviction. This requirement acts as a check on the governor’s executive authority.
How many death row inmates are affected by the proposed change?
The proposal impacts 548 individuals currently sentenced to death in California.
What happens next in the legal process?
The California Supreme Court has not yet announced how or when it will handle the reviews for the 382 cases that require its recommendation. In the meantime, the court is considering the petition from prosecutors and victims’ families to halt the process. CNN’s Dahlia Faheid and Elizabeth Wolfe contributed to this report.