Why Oil Company Profits Are Rising Again

Major oil companies pulled in just over $36 billion in earnings for the quarter, driven by a global supply disruption and soaring crude prices tied to the ongoing war in Iran, according to financial reports released this week. ExxonMobil earned $15.4 billion, more than doubling its earnings compared to the same period last year. Shell nearly doubled its own earnings at $10.8 billion, while Chevron reported profits up 180% at $9.9 billion.

Global Supply Shocks Propel Brent Crude to $113 a Barrel

The profits stem from a major disruption in the Middle East that has restricted oil flow through the region, raising the value of crude produced elsewhere in the world. Brent crude now trades around $113 a barrel, compared to roughly $70 a barrel before the conflict began. Demand for oil and refined products like gasoline, diesel, and heating oil remains steady as consumers continue to heat homes and drive cars.

Dan Pickering, founder of Pickering Energy Partners, noted that producers in the U.S., Latin America, and Europe are capitalizing on the higher price environment. “The majors are able to sell their barrels that they produce in the U.S. or Latin America or Europe for much higher prices,” Pickering said, adding that “the Middle East’s loss is generally the gain of oil and gas companies in the U.S. and Europe.”

Executives return quarterly windfall cash to shareholders

Energy executives told investors that a significant portion of the quarterly windfall is returning to shareholders through dividends and stock buybacks. Shell executed one of its largest buybacks ever, while Exxon announced its highest-ever quarterly dividend. Despite the cash influx, Pickering explained that major firms are maintaining a cautious, wait-and-see stance rather than pouring capital into new drilling projects.

A pump jack operates at sunset in the Permian Basin near Loving, N.M., on Tuesday, May 20, 2025
Photo: ksut.org

Because these elevated prices stem from geopolitical events rather than standard market growth, executives prefer to hold cash reserves. “You put the money in the bank and watch to see what happens as we move into 2027,” Pickering said, noting that oil remains a cyclical industry where companies insulate themselves against future downturns.

Consumers face higher costs at retail stations

Data from AAA shows that filling up a vehicle at a retail station is now more expensive, with a gallon of gasoline costing roughly $1.20 higher than it did at this point last year.

Diesel prices also hovered near record highs set in September. On earnings calls, Exxon CEO Darren Woods acknowledged the financial strain on households, stating that his teams are working to maximize production in response to the shortage. Chevron CEO Mike Wirth echoed that sentiment, emphasizing that management is focused on helping consumers get as much fuel out of company systems as possible.

Executives pointed to compounding pressures from the war in Iran and Ukraine’s strikes on Russian oil refineries, which have taken significant refining capacity offline. Shell CEO Wael Sawan noted that global reserves are dwindling rapidly, pointing to low levels in the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve and European crude releases. “We’re now seeing more and more structural stability in that higher oil price simply because we are seeing that inventory levels are being drawn down very quickly,” Sawan told investors.

Lawmakers push for a windfall profits tax

The soaring corporate earnings have renewed congressional pushes for a windfall profits tax. Lawmakers belonging to the Democratic Party across both houses of Congress have advocated for levying a charge on unexpected financial gains driven by external geopolitical events rather than corporate innovation.

Meanwhile, the administration has implemented measures ahead of the midterms to lower fuel costs, including temporarily loosening federal rules for dyed diesel used in agriculture and lifting certain sanctions on Russian diesel. However, analysts note that these steps will have a limited impact on domestic prices because the volume of Russian diesel released represents only a small fraction of daily U.S. demand, and dyed diesel remains restricted for standard drivers.

Frequently Asked Questions About Oil Profits and Fuel Prices

Why are oil company profits surging while global supply is restricted?

While the war in Iran has disrupted Middle Eastern supply routes, the oil produced in other regions has become much more valuable. Companies operating outside the conflict zone are selling their barrels at significantly higher global prices while meeting steady consumer demand.

How are oil companies spending their billions in quarterly earnings?

Energy firms are directing substantial portions of their cash windflows toward shareholders via dividends and stock buybacks. Executives are generally avoiding large-scale spending on new drilling projects, preferring to hoard cash in case geopolitical prices drop.

What legislative actions are lawmakers proposing to address high oil revenues?

Congressional Democrats have called for a tax on windfall profits generated by geopolitical forces outside of their control.

Can recent administrative policy changes lower fuel costs at U.S. pumps?

Federal measures—such as easing rules for dyed diesel and lifting some Russian sanctions—are unlikely to significantly reduce U.S. prices because the released volumes represent only a tiny portion of daily domestic demand.

According to AAA figures, retail gasoline prices currently stand at approximately $1.20 higher per gallon than they were twelve months ago.