Art investments vastly underperformed traditional stock markets over the 10-year period ending in 2024, producing some of the worst returns in seven decades, CNBC reported. Specialists stress that the art sector is exceptionally opaque and relies heavily on insider knowledge, despite modest gains in 2025 and a stronger 2026 driven by a surge in younger purchasers.
Why Art Underperforms Traditional Markets and Stock Indexes
An evaluation of annualized 10-year performance figures incorporating statistics up through 2024 revealed that equities drastically beat art investments, delivering some of the weakest decade-long returns seen in seventy years.
What I tell people is that there is so much inside information in the art world — for instance, who has bought a particular artist or who is getting a museum show in two years — that if you are an outsider, you have little hope
of catching early market movements, Prendergast said. Magnus Resch, who teaches art economics at Yale University, echoed that assessment, stating that most art is not a good investment and that buyers on a limited budget are unlikely to see financial returns.
How Galleries and Auctions Drive Artist Valuations
Operating in the art market requires understanding its two-tiered structure: the primary market, consisting of galleries, and the secondary market, typically made up of auctions.
Prendergast advised that collectors should pay close attention to mid-career artists and visit major art fairs, where up-and-coming galleries are frequently placed in the corners.
Budget-Based Strategies for Buying Art From Prints to Blue-Chip Works
According to the 2026 Art Basel and UBS Survey of Global Collecting, which surveyed 3,100 collectors across 10 markets, painting remains the dominant medium, accounting for 76% of buyer participation and 31% of total fine art expenditure. Sculpture ranked second at 15%, followed by works on paper at 10% and digital art at 9%.
For collectors operating on specific budgets, Yale art economics expert Magnus Resch offered targeted allocation strategies:
- $5,000 Budget: Look for prints or works on paper by blue-chip artists, ideally purchased at auction. Resch warned that emerging artists can sell out gallery shows yet still have virtually no resale market.
- $10,000 Budget: Explore original contemporary art day sales at major auction houses. Georgina Adam, editor at large for The Art Newspaper, noted that while $10,000 is a significant sum, it is not life-changing if lost, though lower-priced items in 19th-century painting, antiques, silver, and porcelain can be very difficult to resell.
- $100,000 Budget: Focus on exceptional individual works by established artists represented by leading galleries who have exhibited at major museums, preferring one high-quality piece over multiple lower-tier acquisitions.
Hidden Costs and Fees That Impact Total Returns
Roman Kräussl, a professor of finance at the Bayes Business School in London specializing in alternative asset classes, explained that transactional expenses severely impact net returns. Buyer’s premiums, shipping, insurance, framing, secure storage, and resale fees all erode profit margins. Kräussl’s research indicates that art provides a lower risk-adjusted return than financial markets, though it can serve as a portfolio hedge against broader financial risks.
Because of these friction costs, experts advise keeping purchases local and personal. Kräussl recommended buying art directly from local galleries, Instagram artists, or direct-exhibition art fairs, treating the purchase as cultural engagement rather than a wealth-building exercise. Art is the most illiquid, nontransparent, opaque investment you can engage with. But it is also tons of fun,
Kräussl said.
Common Collector Questions About Entering the Art Market
Are digital art and prints safe alternatives to original paintings?
Digital art accounted for 9% of fine art spending in the 2026 Art Basel and UBS survey. Resch noted that prints and authorized editions offer access to blue-chip artists at a fraction of the original cost, though buyers should verify that an artist maintains an active auction market before purchasing.
Worth a look