Why Surgery Could Not Save Fiona the Hippo After Swallowing a Cap

Fiona, the Cincinnati Zoo hippo who survived a record-low premature birth in 2017, died Thursday after swallowing a knit cap that became lodged deep in her small intestine, making surgical removal impossible, zoo officials said. A necropsy confirmed the hat sat 7.6 metres past her final stomach compartment, beyond the reach of endoscopy, and no supportive care could have saved the 1,088-kilogram animal.

How did the hat reach Fiona’s habitat?

A visitor tossed the knit cap into the air in front of the Hippo Cove viewing area. The cap caught on a ceiling fan, which flung it through a 30-centimetre opening above the 3.6-metre-tall viewing windows, Cincinnati Zoo communications director Michelle Curley told rnz.co.nz. “We probably couldn’t make [it] happen again if we tried,” Curley told the BBC.

Why could veterinarians not remove the obstruction?

The hat lodged in the middle of Fiona’s small intestine — 7.6 metres beyond the final stomach compartment and 15 metres from the end of her intestines, the zoo’s necropsy showed. “Upper and lower GI endoscopy were unable to reach the object,” Cincinnati Zoo director of animal health Dr Mike Wenninger said.

“The location and anatomy made laparoscopic removal impossible,” he added, noting the 2,400-pound hippo’s thick skin would have made a long open incision a near-certain death sentence. Zoo Miami associate veterinarian and hippo expert Dr Gabriella Flacke, who consulted on the case, explained to rnz.co.nz that hippo skin is designed to insulate and protect but heals poorly after large surgical cuts.

What did the necropsy reveal about Fiona’s final days?

The post-mortem confirmed the hat caused a complete blockage. “No treatment, aside from supportive care, had any chance for success and the necropsy confirmed that no amount of supportive care would have worked,” Wenninger said. Fiona’s appetite decreased days after ingestion, and keepers tried to encourage eating to move the object naturally, but the hat’s position made passage impossible, the BBC reported.

How did Fiona become a global sensation?

Born six weeks early in 2017 at 29 pounds (13.1 kg) — about half the previous lowest recorded birth weight for a Nile hippo — Fiona could not stand to nurse. Keepers formed “Team Fiona” for round-the-clock tube feeding and care, a struggle documented daily on social media that drew millions of followers. “She gave us almost a decade of smiles,” zoo director Dave Jenike said.

What has been the public response?

Fans left flowers, handwritten notes, watermelons and pumpkins at a hippo statue outside the habitat. Cincinnati landmarks — stadiums, bridges and buildings — were lit purple in tribute. The U.S. Senate adopted a resolution honouring Fiona on Friday, the BBC noted. “The support that we’re feeling from all over the world reminds me of the time when everyone pulled together to root for her to survive,” Jenike said.

How are the other hippos reacting?

Fiona’s mother Bibi, half-brother Fritz and male Tucker are eating and behaving normally, animal care director Christina Gorsuch said. “It’s difficult to know how they’re feeling, but they appear to be their normal selves,” she told rnz.co.nz. Hippo Cove remains closed through the weekend to give the care team space.

Is foreign-object ingestion a known risk for zoo hippos?

Yes. Dr Flacke told rnz.co.nz she is aware of “at least a dozen or more other cases in zoos around the world” where hippos died from intestinal blockages caused by balls, children’s toys or similar items. Aquatic animals investigate splashes and often ingest the object, she explained. The design of close-viewing habitats makes it possible for items to fall or be thrown in, whether accidentally or deliberately.

What safety changes are being discussed?

American Veterinary Medical Association president Dr Jennifer Quammen told rnz.co.nz that securing personal belongings near habitats, respecting barriers and keeping potentially dangerous objects out of reach “can go a long way to keep animals safe.”

Association of Zoos & Aquariums executive vice president Melissa Howerton called Fiona’s death a “tragic and unusual accident” and said accredited zoos build “empathy for the natural world” by connecting visitors with animals few would otherwise experience.

Why are people comparing Fiona to Harambe?

Both animals became Cincinnati Zoo icons whose deaths sparked intense online reactions, but under vastly different circumstances. Harambe, a 17-year-old western lowland gorilla, was shot in 2016 to save a child who entered his enclosure, prompting outrage and debates over zoo safety.

Fiona’s death followed an accidental ingestion with no human fault assigned to staff. Visitor Debby Manning told CNN affiliate WKRC that Fiona’s early struggle “inspired a lot of people, particularly after Harambe.”

How long did Fiona live?

Fiona was 9 years old. Nile hippos in managed care typically live into their 30s or 40s, so her death cut short an expected lifespan of several more decades.

Fiona the hippo is seen during the annual PNC Festival of Lights Christmas Celebration at the Cincinnati Zoo and Botanical
Photo: BBC

Fiona’s legacy: what happens next?

The zoo has not announced a permanent memorial plan. Hippo Cove will reopen after the weekend closure. “She was magic wrapped in a hippo,” primary keeper Jenna Wingate wrote on Instagram. “Not that we would or could ever forget her, but I’m not sure how we will find relief from the reminders of her anywhere we go.”

Frequently asked questions about Fiona’s death

What exactly killed Fiona?

A knit cap lodged in the middle of her small intestine caused a fatal blockage. The necropsy confirmed no medical or surgical intervention could have reached or removed it.

Removal of hat inside Fiona the hippo was 'impossible', Cincinnati Zoo says. #BBCNews — BBC News

Was the hat thrown on purpose?

No. A visitor tossed the cap in the air; a ceiling fan caught it and catapulted it through a small opening above the viewing windows, the zoo’s communications director said.

Could surgery have saved her?

Veterinarians determined a long open incision on a 1,088-kg hippo would have been a death sentence because hippo skin heals poorly after large cuts. Laparoscopic and endoscopic tools could not reach the object’s depth.

Are the other hippos at risk?

The zoo says Bibi, Fritz and Tucker are eating and behaving normally. Hippo Cove remains closed temporarily for staff space, not due to a habitat hazard.

Has this happened to other zoo hippos?

Yes. A consulting hippo veterinarian said she knows of at least a dozen cases worldwide where hippos died from ingesting foreign objects such as balls or toys.

The Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden opened in 1875, making it the second oldest zoo in the United States. Its founding traces to the 1872 Society for the Acclimatization of Birds, formed to import insect-eating birds to control a caterpillar outbreak. The zoo was home to Martha, the last living passenger pigeon, and Incas, the last Carolina parakeet, and achieved the first successful breeding of California sea lions.

Fiona the hippo under care after swallowing a hat at Cincinnati Zoo. #BBCNews — BBC News

Reporting from rnz.co.nz, BBC and Stuff.