Indonesia’s shipping policies regarding ZIM Integrated Shipping Services reveal a significant gap between political rhetoric and port operations, according to shipping tracking data and government statements. While Indonesian leaders frequently pledge unwavering support for Palestine, the nation’s regulatory framework bans only Israeli-flagged vessels rather than companies tied to Israel, allowing carriers like the MV Wantai to dock in Jakarta and Surabaya under flags of convenience.
The Policy Loophole: Flags vs. Company Ownership
The contradiction in Indonesia’s maritime approach stems from a strict focus on a vessel’s registry rather than its corporate parentage. According to the Indonesian Transport Ministry’s spokesperson, authorities have never issued a permit to any ship flying the Israeli flag. Instead, enforcement relies entirely on the flag a ship carries at sea.
Container ships routinely utilize flags of convenience from nations like Liberia, Panama, or the Marshall Islands to secure lower operational costs and lighter regulation. For example, ZIM operates the South China Indonesia Service connecting Xiamen, Nansha, Jakarta, Surabaya, and Yantian. Shipping data shows that vessels on this route, such as the 210-meter-long MV Wantai with a capacity of roughly 2,890 containers, sail under the Liberian flag.
Because the MV Wantai carries a Liberian registry instead of an Israeli one, it legally accesses Indonesian ports like Jakarta and Surabaya. This operational reality contrasts with statements from then-President Joko Widodo, who stated in January 2024 that Indonesian ports would not serve Israeli interests amid public pressure over Gaza.
Did you know? Indonesia’s constitution explicitly calls on the state to help build a world order based on freedom, lasting peace, and social justice, a principle frequently invoked by leaders from Sukarno to Prabowo Subianto when discussing Palestine.
Contrasting Approaches: Indonesia and Malaysia
Regional neighbors have adopted starkly different mechanisms to enforce economic stances against Israeli-linked entities. In December 2023, the Malaysian government instituted a direct ban on any vessel owned by ZIM, regardless of the flag displayed on its hull, alongside a blanket prohibition on Israeli-flagged ships.
Malaysia’s model closes the corporate loophole that remains active in Indonesian waters. By targeting the shipping line itself rather than the registry of individual vessels, Kuala Lumpur eliminated the possibility of ZIM-chartered ships utilizing flags of convenience to bypass national restrictions.
According to campaigners, closing this gap in Indonesia would require the Transport Ministry to broaden its restrictions to cover any vessel operated or chartered by ZIM. Additionally, parliament could request that the ministry transparently and publicly disclose the exact count of ZIM-associated port visits in Indonesia starting from January 2024, as well as clarify the absence of updates to the flag-exclusive regulation, noting that Ahmad Muzani, the Speaker of Indonesia’s People’s Consultative Assembly, addressed parliament in Jakarta in August 2026 to affirm that Indonesia’s backing of Palestine remains steadfast.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Indonesia ban all ships linked to Israel?
No. Indonesia only bans ships flying the Israeli flag. Vessels owned or operated by Israeli companies like ZIM are permitted to dock as long as they sail under a third-party registry, such as a flag of convenience from Liberia or Panama.
What is a flag of convenience?
Typically, this refers to the banner of nations such as Panama, Liberia, or the Marshall Islands, selected to benefit from reduced expenses and minimal oversight.
How does Malaysia’s policy differ from Indonesia’s?
By prohibiting all ZIM-owned ships irrespective of their registry alongside Israeli-flagged vessels, Malaysia effectively eliminated any workaround involving flags of convenience.
The opinions expressed in this piece are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official stance or editorial position of Middle East Monitor.
Keep reading