Woman Dies After Port Hardy ER Closure, Sparks Demands for 24-Hour Service

A woman died on Thursday evening after arriving at the Port Hardy Hospital emergency room shortly after its 5 p.m. closure, sparking renewed demands for the facility to restore 24-hour service.

Island Health confirmed the death on Friday, stating that care providers and B.C. Emergency Health Services paramedics performed emergency interventions. Paramedics were called to the scene at 5:11 p.m. after becoming aware of a patient in critical condition in the hospital parking lot. Two additional ambulances arrived to assist before the woman was transferred to hospital staff, where she could not be resuscitated.

Dr. Alex Nataros, director of the North Island Community Health Centre, said that the patient was in her 40s.

While the exact cause of death remains under investigation by the B.C. Coroners Service, Nataros said that the incident has shaken the local community.

Paramedics Performed Prolonged CPR Outside Hospital

According to B.C. Emergency Health Services, paramedics performed CPR outside the facility “for a prolonged period of time.”

Nataros, who was not at the hospital during the incident, described this as an unusual occurrence. He added that a colleague conducting rounds inside the 18-bed hospital was left shaken by the event.

“There’s been deaths, and too many deaths,” said Nataros.

Island Health is currently reviewing the circumstances of the death alongside B.C. Emergency Health Services. The health authority said that it would be “inappropriate to speculate on any factors that may have contributed” while the review is ongoing.

Hospital service status and regional impacts

Facility Status
Port Hardy Hospital Closed 5 p.m. to 7 a.m.
Port McNeill Hospital 24-hour acute-care

The emergency department at Port Hardy has operated on a restricted schedule since January 2023, when Island Health implemented temporary overnight closures citing staffing shortages. Patients requiring emergency care after 5 p.m. must travel 40 kilometres to the facility in Port McNeill. Nataros, who was suspended by Island Health in 2023 following complaints regarding patient safety, argued that the current management of local health resources is inadequate.

“They need to put on their scrubs and get back to delivering patient care,” Nataros said, claiming there are more managers at the 18-bed hospital than emergency room nurses.

He added that the closure forces chronically ill patients to face significant physical and mental suffering. During the fall election campaign, Premier Lorne Doerkson pledged to establish a $50-million emergency fund to prevent hospital closures and support recruitment.

“We are desperate up here,” said Nataros.

Island Health implemented the restricted schedule in January 2023 to manage regional staffing shortages by concentrating overnight emergency services at the Port McNeill facility. Port Hardy Hospital, which handles over 6,000 emergency department visits annually, has seen this temporary consolidation persist as health officials struggle to recruit and retain medical professionals in the underserved community.

Local leaders indicate that despite ongoing advocacy, no clear timeline exists for restoring 24-hour operations. While the province recently announced a $45-million expansion and upgrade for the hospital, including improvements to the emergency department, these facility enhancements are phased for completion by 2029 and do not currently guarantee the return of overnight services.

Anna Kindy, the newly appointed minister of state for rural development, also campaigned on reopening the Port Hardy emergency department. While local doctors signed a letter to Island Health last month calling for the immediate restoration of 24-hour services, provincial officials, including Health Minister Ryan Peterson, were unable to provide immediate comment on the situation on Friday following their swearing-in ceremonies. It remains unclear why the patient was not transported to the 24-hour emergency room in Port McNeill. “It’s outrageous that we are not the primary emergency room open 24/7 north of Campbell River,” said Nataros.