World Rugby to Review Rassie Erasmus’ Comments on Officiating Standards

Seventeen knee-drop tackles went unpenalized during South Africa’s narrow loss to France, according to Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus, who questioned whether the missed incidents pointed toward manipulation of the result.

The Springboks hold a record of 20 wins, 10 losses, and one draw from 31 historical matches against Ireland.

Sky Sports reported that World Rugby will review those comments under its match official abuse sanction framework, which was introduced earlier this year to curb threats and abuse directed at referees.

The governing body’s independent three-person panel will determine whether the remarks were made to undermine confidence in officials, with potential penalties ranging up to multiple match bans. In 2021, Erasmus was banned from all rugby activity for two months for his behavior towards match officials during a Test series, which included releasing an hour-long video critiquing a referee’s display.

Erasmus pointed specifically to the officiating display during Friday’s encounter in Paris, where referee Andrea Piardi and television match official Matteo Liperini oversaw the contest, according to The South African. A disallowed try for Kurt-Lee Arendse and unrewarded late scrum dominance drew scrutiny.

“Let’s say 11 of those were at least a penalty and three I thought was at least three yellow cards. And not one was sanctioned and not one was showed out or cited,” Erasmus said.

“So we’ll probably query it, but the answer will be, ‘Yes, it was a mistake.’ They should have penalised that,” Erasmus said. Ultimately, he insisted he was not making an “accusation,” but simply highlighting the difficulty of understanding why World Rugby meetings do not lead to action.

“If he saw it and ignored it, what does that boil down to? Manipulation of the game or the result? Or players getting injured?” he added. “So, all I’m asking is don’t take the TMOs out and discourage them to get involved.”

The Independent said that World Rugby declined to comment on the remarks. The governing body’s sanction process has already seen Italy coach Gonzalo Quesada disciplined under the new rules during the opening phase of the competition.

Sam Prendergast Citation Status

Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast faces a disciplinary review for an alleged illegal hip-drop tackle on Fiji captain Peceli Yato during a 43-15 victory, SA Rugby magazine reported. Yato scored shortly after the incident but was forced off the pitch with an injury. According to The 42, the incident could impact Prendergast’s availability for Saturday’s match, particularly as hip-drop tackles were officially outlawed at the start of the current international window.

SA Rugby magazine also said that a citing commissioner must determine that the foul play meets the threshold for a red card before issuing a formal charge. Connacht fly-half Ciarán Frawley stands as the primary candidate to wear the No 10 jersey if Prendergast receives a suspension before Saturday’s fixture.

Erasmus told reporters on Monday that he expects the Ireland playmaker to escape punishment on a technicality ahead of the fixture at the Aviva Stadium, pointing to differing standards between hemispheres. “We are in the northern hemisphere,” Erasmus said. “I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.”

World Rugby to Review Rassie Erasmus' Comments on Officiating Standards
Photo: SA Rugby magazine

The Independent added that Erasmus compared the incident to a previous nine-week ban given to South Africa player Jan-Hendrik Wessels for a similar tackle, noting that the differing outcomes created a frustrating double standard for his squad. “Everybody watched the game live because that’s exactly what they said the hip-drop tackle is,” he said. “I swear I’m not moaning.”

Dublin Showdown Preparation

Head coach Andy Farrell holds a three-win advantage across five previous meetings against the Springboks, though South Africa claimed victory in their last encounter in Dublin twelve months ago, a match that featured five yellow cards shown to Irish players.

The Springboks announced a squad featuring the recall of lock Eben Etzebeth as preparations continue for the weekend fixture. Ireland’s coaching staff planned to confirm their final team selection later in the week.

“It’s difficult to understand when the TMO sits there and sees that,” Erasmus said of the tackle involving Prendergast. It couldn’t have been missed.”

"IS THAT NOT MATCH-Fixing?" – Rassie Erasmus on France's 16 knee drop tackles — Forever Sports

Answering Match Questions

  • When do Ireland play South Africa?
    The two sides meet on Saturday at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin for their Nations Championship fixture.
  • Who refereed the France versus South Africa match?
    Andrea Piardi served as the referee in Paris, with Matteo Liperini operating as the television match official, according to The South African.
  • What penalty did Jan-Hendrik Wessels receive previously?
    Jan-Hendrik Wessels was handed a nine-week suspension for a tackle that South Africa representatives compared to the incident involving Sam Prendergast, as reported by The Independent.