Zelda: Ocarina of Time User Score Drops to 8.7 After GTA 6 Review Bombing

Zelda: Ocarina of Time user score dropped from 9.6 to 8.7 after angry fans flooded Metacritic with zeroes.

Grand Theft Auto 6 faces a sharp divide on Metacritic, where a user score of 5,6 out of 10 contrasts with a critical average of 99 points, notebookcheck-hu.com reported, according to Notebookcheck Hu.

That massive discrepancy triggered a wave of coordinated negative ratings. Some frustrated players targeted a rival contender for game of the year, dragging down the score for the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake.

Review Bombing Hits Zelda Classic

The Zelda remake saw its user score drop from 9,6 to 8,7 after angry fans flooded the platform with zeroes. The Switch 2 title maintained a stable score after Metacritic opened user reviews on November 6, but dropped in less than 24 hours.

That coordinated action struck a game that had gathered at least 20,000 reviews since its release. Critics praised the Rockstar title just as they did the N64-era Zelda classic, leaving both tied at the top of critical rankings before public scores emerged.

Statistical Proof of Targeted Attacks

Zero-point reviews contained personal insults directed at developers or players enjoying the story of Lucia and Jason rather than gameplay critiques. A Reddit user named gtrhawk analyzed 14,000 user reviews to uncover the mechanics behind the score drops.

Grand theft auto vi rockstar games
Photo: GSPlus.hu

The analysis revealed that 83.8% of users who left negative reviews for GTA 6 did not score the modernised Zelda. By contrast, only 33.5% of those who slammed Ocarina of Time failed to rate the Rockstar game as well.

Game Title Critical Score User Score Review Volume
Grand Theft Auto 6 99 5.5 / 10 Over 40,000
Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake Not stated 8.7 / 10 20,000+

Platform Vulnerabilities Exposed

Observers argue that this back-and-forth feuding exposes a fundamental flaw in the Metacritic user evaluation system. Users only need to register an email address without verifying ownership of the game.

GSPlus.hu reported that the November 19 premiere brought over 40,000 ratings for GTA 6, resulting in an aggregate score of 5.5 out of 10 from players. Insider Gaming said that Backloggd showed a slightly more favorable score of 3.9 out of 5.

Technical hiccups, performance issues, and PC players waiting for a port fueled the backlash alongside cultural interpretations of the main characters. Observers note it remains impossible to verify how many negative scores reflect actual playtime.

Common Questions About the Score Divide

Why did the Zelda remake get low ratings?

Fans of Rockstar’s crime title targeted the Nintendo classic in a retaliatory review-bombing campaign after GTA 6 received thousands of zero-point user scores.

How do critical and user scores compare for GTA 6?

The game holds a 99 Metascore based on 158 PlayStation 5 reviews and 14 Xbox Series X|S reviews, while tens of thousands of users pushed the player average down to 5.5 out of 10.

Metacritic launched in January 2001 after two years of development by Marc Doyle, his sister Julie Doyle Roberts, and their University of Southern California law classmate Jason Dietz; Rotten Tomatoes already covered films, but the trio saw an opening to aggregate reviews across a broader range of media.

The site was acquired by CNET in 2005, later passing to CBS Corporation, then Red Ventures in 2020, and finally to Fandom, Inc. in 2022. It is regarded as the foremost online review aggregation site for the video game industry, and its Metascores have been used by publishers to determine developer bonuses, most notably when Fallout: New Vegas missed a contractual threshold by a single point in 2010.

Does Metacritic require proof of purchase?

No verification is required, as users only need a registered email address to submit a score on the platform.