AI Shopping Tools Deliver Mixed Black Friday Results

Generative AI tools deliver mixed results when tasked with finding Black Friday shopping deals, often serving up dead links, out-of-date pricing, and unavailable products. Testing conducted ahead of the sales event revealed that chatbots frequently struggled with live inventory data.

Figures suggest relatively few UK shoppers currently go to AI tools for help. Based on a recent YouGov poll spanning 19 nations, the UK positioned second-to-last regarding the share of individuals reporting they used AI to help them shop.

Notably, 36% of participants indicating they intended to shop around Black Friday had zero intention of employing an artificial intelligence assistant. However, the polling indicated an escalating interest among consumers—prompting technology companies to roll out new capabilities to harness this demand.

Chatbot deal tests reveal dead links

In November, Amazon introduced Alexa for Shopping for users in the UK, while OpenAI released a Shopping Research feature on ChatGPT just days prior to Black Friday last year. Meanwhile, Google recently rolled out Universal Cart in the US, introducing artificial intelligence-driven functions including price tracking and the detection of applicable discount codes.

When free versions of popular tools were asked to find a 55-inch TV deal, OpenAI’s ChatGPT came up with four options. Its primary choice featured a Hisense television listed on the Chinese e-commerce site Joybuy’s website, on sale for £499 down from £649. The subsequent suggestion was a 55-inch TCL television, though a side panel displayed costs for the 50-inch variant ranging between £379 and £814.

Option three was the same Hisense TV as before, but for full price at £649 from John Lewis and Richer Sounds. This was the “best safer purchase” according to ChatGPT, as the sites offered longer guarantee periods.

Both retailers said the TV was no longer listed online. The fourth option was another TCL TV, at full price, £150 over the budget and not available online.

At the bottom, ChatGPT served one last offer – “one OLED option to compare” – for a £1,100 LG TV that was marked as “Ad”. Claude produced the shortest answer of all the models tested, and unlike the others, it did not give much detail on the specifications of each model.

Claude recommended the same two TCL TVs, but the links sent testers to two dead pages on the Richer Sounds website. Other links led to year-old round-ups of Black Friday 2025 deals.

Alexa returns inconsistent TV prices and data

Alexa came back with four TVs, from its own Amazon Ember at £532 to a £699 Samsung. Its top recommendation was to go for another Samsung model at £616 down from £749, based on reviews and delivery times. Alexa did acknowledge this, encouraging users to check its rivals for better deals, “as prices can vary” and longer guarantees could be obtained elsewhere.

Media professional Alex Hughes experienced better fortune when utilizing the agentic AI mode on ChatGPT to track down a television during the previous year’s Black Friday promotions.

A year on, he didn’t go through with buying a TV at that time. He later purchased one of the seven models ChatGPT had surfaced, but found it for a lower price in a bricks-and-mortar shop.

When asked if he would use AI to find Black Friday deals again, he said “probably not”, adding that while it saved him time, “when you’re trying to deal with something like live price data, it will be inconsistent and quite often incorrect”.

Naureen Mohammed, who counsels enterprises on optimizing their merchandise for visibility in artificial intelligence outputs, mentioned to the BBC that shoppers miss the complete picture when interacting with conversational bots. If businesses fail to update their prices when people start hunting for bargains, “last year’s prices are served up as today’s deals”.

Her examination of conversational agents’ technological discounts in the United Kingdom during Black Friday pointed toward major vendors dominating the results. Amazon appeared in half of the responses, closely followed by Currys.

Her tips include asking an assistant “is that this year’s price?” and clicking on the provided links “because you shouldn’t take any advice from the AI system at face value”.

YouGov, the international market research and data analytics firm headquartered in the UK, was founded in May 2000 by Stephan Shakespeare and Nadhim Zahawi. It became a public company on the London Stock Exchange’s Alternative Investment Market in 2005.

The firm gained prominence for pioneering the multi-level regression and post-stratification (MRP) methodology in political polling, which correctly predicted a hung parliament in the 2017 UK General Election when most other pollsters projected a large Conservative majority. In July 2023, YouGov agreed to acquire the consumer panel division of German rival GfK for €315 million.

Consumer group Which? recently said that inaccurate pricing in AI results added more work to Black Friday deal-hunting. Senior researcher Hannah Walsh said that if users ask for a list of 10 items under a certain price and several results are priced higher, time is wasted sorting through them to discover the bot provided fewer viable options.