The Delivery Dilemma: Restaurants Rethink the Third-Party App Equation
The pandemic turbocharged third-party delivery, turning it into a lifeline for restaurants. But as the dust settles, a growing number of operators are realizing that convenience comes at a cost – a significant bite out of already-thin profit margins. The story of Big Red F, a Colorado-based restaurant group, is becoming increasingly common, signaling a potential shift in how restaurants approach off-premise dining.
The Rise and Fall of the Delivery Boom
During the height of lockdowns, services like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub were essential. Big Red F saw delivery account for up to 40% of sales on peak nights. Nationally, consumer spending on these platforms continues to climb – DoorDash processed over $72 billion in the first three quarters of 2023, a 23% increase year-over-year. Uber Eats saw a 20% jump, reaching $65 billion in orders.
However, the initial euphoria has faded. The high commission fees – ranging from 10% to 30% per order – are proving unsustainable for many. As Dave Query of Big Red F discovered, the revenue generated often doesn’t outweigh the expenses. This isn’t just a problem for independent restaurants; even larger chains are scrutinizing the economics.
Did you know? A recent Market Leader report found that 53% of restaurant operators are actively trying to reduce their reliance on third-party delivery services.
The Search for Alternatives: Direct Ordering and Hybrid Models
Restaurants are exploring several strategies to regain control of their off-premise business. The most prominent is a return to direct ordering – encouraging customers to order through the restaurant’s website or app. Big Red F now directs all delivery orders through its own channels, utilizing third-party services solely for fulfillment.
This approach allows restaurants to retain more revenue and, crucially, access valuable customer data. However, it requires investment in technology and marketing to drive traffic to direct channels. Partners Coffee in New York City is launching its own mobile app to incentivize direct orders, offering loyalty rewards and exclusive deals.
A hybrid model is also gaining traction. Restaurants continue to list on third-party apps to maintain visibility but actively promote direct ordering through packaging inserts, email marketing, and social media. This allows them to balance reach with profitability.
The App Response: Tiered Commissions and Marketing Push
Delivery apps aren’t standing still. They’ve introduced tiered commission structures, offering lower rates for basic services and higher rates for increased visibility and access to premium customers. However, 50% of operators still cite third-party fees as the biggest challenge to off-premise growth, according to the Market Leader report.
Furthermore, apps are increasingly pushing restaurants to invest in advertising within their platforms. This adds another layer of cost, potentially negating any savings from tiered commissions. Stella Dennig of Daytrip Counter in Oakland, California, is facing a suggested advertising budget of $637 per week – a significant expense for a small restaurant.
The Future of Restaurant Delivery: Consolidation and Innovation
Several trends are likely to shape the future of restaurant delivery:
- Increased Consolidation: Smaller restaurants may struggle to compete with the high costs of delivery, potentially leading to consolidation within the industry.
- Ghost Kitchens: The rise of ghost kitchens – delivery-only restaurants – will continue, offering a lower-cost alternative to traditional brick-and-mortar locations.
- Restaurant-Led Delivery Networks: Independent restaurants may explore forming cooperative delivery networks to negotiate better rates and share resources.
- Technological Advancements: Improvements in delivery logistics, such as drone delivery and autonomous vehicles, could reduce costs and improve efficiency.
- Focus on First-Party Data: Restaurants will prioritize building direct relationships with customers to capture valuable data and personalize the dining experience.
Pro Tip: Invest in a user-friendly online ordering system and actively promote it to your customers. Consider offering incentives for direct orders, such as discounts or loyalty points.
FAQ: Navigating the Delivery Landscape
- Q: Are third-party delivery apps still valuable for restaurants?
A: Yes, they provide valuable reach and convenience, especially for attracting new customers. However, restaurants need to carefully weigh the costs and benefits. - Q: What is the average commission fee charged by third-party delivery apps?
A: Commission fees typically range from 10% to 30% per order, depending on the service level and negotiated rates. - Q: How can restaurants reduce their reliance on third-party delivery?
A: Strategies include investing in direct ordering channels, offering incentives for direct orders, and exploring alternative delivery solutions. - Q: Will delivery apps lower their commission fees in the future?
A: While some apps have introduced tiered commission structures, significant reductions are unlikely without increased competition or regulatory pressure.
The delivery landscape is complex and constantly evolving. Restaurants must adapt and innovate to navigate the challenges and capitalize on the opportunities. The future likely lies in a balanced approach – leveraging the reach of third-party apps while prioritizing direct customer relationships and profitability.
Reader Question: What strategies have you implemented to manage the costs of third-party delivery? Share your experiences in the comments below!
Explore more articles on restaurant marketing and profitability.
