Memorial head track coach Rob Starr took the witness stand to recount the events of April 2, 2025, a day when his team served as the host school for a track meet. Starr testified that due to the logistical demands of hosting, he had enlisted student athletes—specifically throwers like Austin and Hunter Metcalf—to assist with setup duties, including managing team tents.
Starr testified that he had been in contact with Austin Metcalf earlier that day, requesting that he step up to assist with the team’s responsibilities. The coach noted that his relationship with the student had been strained heading into the district meet, as he had previously removed Austin Metcalf from the team for leaving a meet early to go fishing, though he later allowed him to return.
A Scene of Chaos
Around 10 a.m., while away from the team area, Starr heard a commotion and rushed back toward the tents. Upon arriving, he discovered Austin Metcalf on the ground with a purple face and a visible wound in his chest. Starr described the scene as chaotic, noting that others were screaming his name and that Hunter Metcalf pleaded with him to intervene.
Starr testified that he was told Karmelo Anthony was responsible for the injury. The coach stated that he approached Anthony, describing the interaction as surreal and non-violent, noting that Anthony appeared hysterical and claimed that the victim had put his hands on him. Starr subsequently moved between the two students, attempting to offer comfort and prayer to both Austin and Hunter Metcalf before ultimately realizing that Austin Metcalf had died.
Looking Ahead
As the legal proceedings continue, the defense is expected to cross-examine Coach Starr to further clarify the timeline of the morning and the specific interactions between the students involved. The trial may continue to focus on the moments leading up to the incident to establish the sequence of events that resulted in the fatality. Further testimony from additional witnesses present at the track meet could provide more context regarding the atmosphere and the alleged altercation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What were the responsibilities of the throwers on the day of the meet?
According to Coach Starr, the throwers were responsible for setting up the tents for the team.
Was there a weather-related delay during the track meet?
Coach Starr testified that there was no rain delay during the event, although he noted that it rained hard for a brief period later in the morning.
What was the nature of the interaction between the coach and Karmelo Anthony?
Starr described the encounter as non-violent and surreal, testifying that Anthony was hysterical and claimed that the victim had put his hands on him.
How do school athletic programs ensure the safety of students when staff are occupied with administrative hosting duties?
