Former 1News Australia correspondent Aziz Al Sa’afin has returned to New Zealand after two years of reporting from Sydney. Despite the economic advantages offered by Australia—including higher wages and lower costs for groceries and petrol—Al Sa’afin’s experience highlights the intangible personal costs of migration, such as the loss of proximity to family and friends during key life moments.
The Economic Case for Moving Across the Tasman
For two years, Al Sa’afin lived in Australia while covering major news events, including federal elections and natural disasters. According to his reporting, the economic disparity between the two nations remained consistent throughout his stay. He noted that on paper, Australia consistently appeared to be the better deal. The average Australian worker earned more, and essential expenses like petrol and household bills were often lower. For many Kiwis, including nurses chasing higher wages, police officers accepting recruitment bonuses, and teachers seeking new opportunities, these economic factors served as the primary motivation for moving. Even today, Al Sa’afin observes that the wage gap remains significant and a trolley of groceries in Australia generally stretches further than in New Zealand.
Why Personal Belonging Outweighs Spreadsheets
Despite the financial incentives, Al Sa’afin chose to return to New Zealand six months ago. He argues that life is measured by more than just bank statements or GDP figures. While living overseas, he missed the ordinary moments that define a life: family dinners, coffee with friends, and weekend barbecues. He describes this as the “exchange rate nobody talks about”—the trade-off between a higher salary and the value of being physically present for loved ones. Even former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has described Australia as a “wonderful place to be,” but Al Sa’afin emphasizes that for him, opportunity and a sense of belonging are distinct concepts.
The Reality of the New Zealand Cost-of-Living Crisis
Al Sa’afin acknowledges that his return to New Zealand does not negate the ongoing economic challenges facing the country. He points out that New Zealand’s cost-of-living crisis remains a reality, with nearly half of Kiwis reporting that they have cut back on fruit and vegetables due to rising prices. While thousands of New Zealanders continue to leave for Australia annually, Al Sa’afin suggests the decision to move—or return—is rarely a simple binary choice. He posits that while Australia may continue to win on many economic arguments, individuals must weigh their own personal calculations regarding where they truly belong.
What May Happen Next for Migrants
The trend of migration between New Zealand and Australia is likely to persist as long as the economic gaps in wages and living costs remain. Analysts may expect that while many will continue to build permanent lives overseas, others may eventually choose to return home as personal circumstances evolve. Because there is no single “right” answer for every family or individual, the movement of people across the Tasman will likely continue to be driven by a mix of economic necessity and the desire for social and familial proximity.
