According to updates shared by procuror Claudiu Sandu on Facebook, the Secția pentru procurori a Consiliului Superior al Magistraturii rejected the Judicial Inspection’s referral regarding a controversial case transfer request filed by Procurorul General Cristina Chiriac. The decision centers on a dosar from the Curtea de Apel Craiova, sparking intense debate over prosecutorial independence and institutional oversight.
CSM Rejects Judicial Inspection Referral After Internal Shift
The Secția pentru procurori a Consiliului Superior al Magistraturii voted by majority to reject the Judicial Inspection referral, according to announcements made by procuror Claudiu Sandu. Initially, all five elected members of the section had jointly initiated the self-referral. However, according to Sandu, some members subsequently changed their stance and decided the referral was unwarranted.
Reporting by HotNews details that the voting process experienced delays, having faced a tie at a previous meeting where three votes favored the referral, three opposed it, and one vote was declared null by procuror Daniel Hordodniceanu. By the final session, with all seven eligible members participating online and in person—including Ministerul Justiției Cătălin Predoiu and Procurorul General Cristina Chiriac—the final tally shifted to four votes against and three in favor of the referral.
Concerns Over Procuror General Intervention in Active Court Files
Critics within the CSM argue that the decision establishes a troubling institutional framework. According to statements published by Claudiu Sandu, the primary issue extends beyond the voting dynamics to the core question of whether the Procuror General possesses the legal authority to intervene in active court files without a clear statutory basis.

Sandu asserts that the action bypassed the trial prosecutor assigned to the case at the Curtea de Apel Craiova, who had previously concluded that neither a case transfer nor the recusal of judecătoarea Sorina Marinaș was necessary. By overriding the trial prosecutor’s stance, the action has triggered sharp comparisons to past political structures, with Sandu warning on social media that practic, ne-am întors înainte de 1989
when the prosecutor’s office operated under heavy state-party alignment.
Did You Know?
Under Romanian procedural frameworks, regular case transfer requests are typically evaluated based on statutory criteria involving security, impartiality, or fair trial concerns within specific lower courts.
The Curtea de Apel Craiova Dispute and EU Law Context
The underlying litigation originates at the Curtea de Apel Craiova, where judecătoarea Sorina Marinaș evaluated whether to refer questions to the Curtea de Justiție a Uniunii Europene regarding the compatibility of investigative mechanisms for crimes committed by magistrates with EU law.

While the supreme court’s jurisdiction to rule on the transfer itself remains a separate procedural matter, members of the CSM like Claudiu Sandu contend that the lack of formal statutory rules enabling the head of the prosecutor’s office to initiate such moves directly undermines the autonomy historically granted to individual prosecutors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the CSM Secția pentru procurori decide regarding the Judicial Inspection?
According to procuror Claudiu Sandu, the section voted by majority to reject the Judicial Inspection referral concerning the transfer request filed by Procurorul General Cristina Chiriac.
Why are members of the CSM raising concerns about the decision?
Critics argue that the ruling sets a precedent allowing the Procuror General to intervene in active court cases without explicit legal backing, bypassing the local trial prosecutor’s evaluation.
Which court originally handled the contested case?
The litigation was initially processed at the Curtea de Apel Craiova before being transferred to the Curtea de Apel București following a decision by the Înalta Curte de Casație și Justiție.
Join the Conversation
What are your thoughts on institutional independence within the judiciary? Share your perspective in the comments below or subscribe to our legal affairs newsletter for ongoing updates.