Damien Ma argues in a column for The Washington Post that top artificial intelligence talent has surpassed oil and gold as the world’s most important commodity.
The competition for human capital is defining the global AI race, with China currently producing significantly more elite researchers than the United States. However, the U.S. maintains a strategic advantage by attracting the highest tier of global experts, many of whom originate from China.
To sustain its technological edge, the U.S. must prioritize an environment of openness and freedom of inquiry. Ma suggests that while national security is a valid concern, policymakers should avoid actions that could cripple American access to the very talent needed to lead the industry.
China leads in STEM degree production
China’s ability to cultivate a deep bench of talent is the result of decades of deliberate effort. This massive scale of education provides a human-capital advantage over American domestic production.
Data shows a stark contrast in the volume of specialized graduates produced by both nations. In 2020, China awarded approximately 1.7 million bachelor’s degrees in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics, excluding social sciences. During that same year, the United States awarded about half a million such degrees.
U.S. dominance relies on global recruitment
While China produces more researchers, the United States remains the primary destination for the “elite of the elite.” Many of the most influential figures in modern AI were born in China or educated there before moving to American institutions.
Computer scientist Kaiming He is one such example. After winning a national physics olympiad in China and studying at Tsinghua University, He worked at Microsoft Research Asia in Beijing.
He later moved to the U.S., where he was recently tenured at MIT. His 2015 paper on deep residual learning is the most cited of the twenty-first century, according to Nature, and its concepts underpin current generative AI models like ChatGPT and Gemini.
Similarly, Stanford University’s Fei-Fei Li, often called the “godmother” of AI, grew up in China’s Sichuan province. She conducted pioneering work at Princeton University before co-founding World Labs, a company recently acquired by AMD for $8.2 billion.
Did you know?
Many American frontier AI models are built using talent of Chinese origin. For instance, reports have suggested that research labs at Meta AI and OpenAI have featured high percentages of Chinese-origin researchers.
Policy shifts and national security
The tension between maintaining national security and attracting global talent complicates policy for American officials. Ma argues that the U.S. needs a long-term strategy to sustain its talent pool while managing the risks of technology transfer to rivals.
One specific area of contention involves immigration restrictions. Ma suggests that the U.S. could signal a more welcoming environment by revoking a presidential proclamation from the first Trump administration that restricted the entry of certain Chinese graduate students and researchers.
While China possesses a massive pool of talent, it currently faces limitations regarding access to high-end semiconductors and essential infrastructure. This creates a paradox where American progress depends heavily on the very talent pool produced by its primary competitor.
China produces triple the STEM graduates of U.S.
What is the main difference between U.S. and Chinese AI advantages?
China’s strength lies in its ability to produce a massive volume of STEM talent through its education system. The United States’ advantage is its capacity to attract and retain the world’s highest-performing researchers.
How large is the STEM graduate gap?
The gap is substantial. In 2020, China produced 1.7 million STEM bachelor’s degrees, which is more than triple the half a million degrees awarded in the United States.
Why is talent considered more important than oil or gold?
Because the development of frontier AI models depends on the specialized knowledge and innovation of elite researchers, human capital is seen as the indispensable ingredient for technological supremacy.
The race for AI supremacy is a marathon that requires both production capacity and the ability to retain high performers, as human capital remains the indispensable ingredient for keeping the U.S. in the lead.