Dementia activists, including Maxine Linnell, Julie Hayden, George Rook, and Kate Swaffer, are challenging the “tragedy narrative” that dominates public perception of dementia. By advocating for “person-centred care” and rejecting “prescribed disengagement,” these experts by experience argue that individuals can lead meaningful, creative, and active lives for years following a diagnosis.
Why is there a shift toward “prescribed disengagement”?
According to Kate Swaffer, an internationally recognized Australian campaigner, “prescribed disengagement” refers to the common medical practice of advising patients to stop working, avoid social interaction, and focus solely on end-of-life planning immediately after diagnosis. Many activists report that this approach is often accompanied by a lack of genuine support beyond potentially patronizing groups.
George Rook, a former teacher from Shropshire diagnosed in 2014 at age 63, recalls being told to avoid risks and not to get tired. He notes that such advice is “absurd” and ignores the necessity of living an active life. Similarly, Julie Hayden, a nurse and social worker diagnosed in 2015 at age 54, reports that she was told there was nothing to be done and she should simply get her affairs in order.
Research cited by activists indicates that half of people in the UK now fear dementia more than any other health condition, a trend that critics argue is worsened by media depictions that focus exclusively on late-stage symptoms and caregiver burdens.
How are activists reframing the dementia experience?
Activists are actively challenging the idea that a diagnosis marks the end of a person’s identity. Maxine Linnell, a 78-year-old retired psychotherapist, argues that dementia does not erase a person’s thoughts, feelings, or creativity. Along with others, she has pushed back against media campaigns like the 2024 Alzheimer’s Society advertisement, “The Long Goodbye,” which she and other steering group members warned could be devastating to the newly diagnosed.
Instead of withdrawing, these activists have founded or joined organizations like the Young Dementia Network and Dementia Alliance International. They are also involved in research, including the “Living Well With Dementia” project. Swaffer, for instance, is currently pursuing a PhD, utilizing the same disability support resources that would be standard for other acquired disabilities.
What is the future of dementia support and rehabilitation?
The path forward, according to activists, involves a departure from the purely biomedical model toward the “person-centred care” advocated by psychologist Tom Kitwood nearly 30 years ago. This includes access to specialized support, such as Admiral nurses, and the integration of lived experience into medical training.
Pro tip: Activists suggest that cognitive rehabilitation and speech therapy—often standard for stroke survivors—should be accessible to those with dementia to help them maintain function and communication skills for as long as possible.
Linnell emphasizes the importance of “deep listening,” noting that even when speech is lost, meaningful connection remains possible. Through her own observations, she has seen individuals regain the ability to communicate when their remaining movements are supported and encouraged by those around them.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is dementia an automatic end to a person’s capability? No. Activists like George Rook argue that the brain is capable of structural adaptation, and many people live active, contributing lives for years after a diagnosis.
- What is “prescribed disengagement”? It is the practice of telling those diagnosed with dementia to stop working and withdraw from society, which activists say is harmful and promotes isolation.
- How can the public better support those with dementia? Experts by experience recommend “deep listening,” focusing on the person behind the condition, and advocating for national, properly funded care pathways that prioritize autonomy.
Have you or a loved one been affected by a dementia diagnosis? Share your experience in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for more updates on advocacy and person-centred care.
