Disney’s Moana remake underperforms with $43M debut vs $250M budget

Disney’s $250 Million Moana Production Budget Faces Profitability Hurdles

Box Office Performance and Budgetary Stakes

The live-action adaptation of Moana arrived in 3,827 North American theaters this weekend, yielding a domestic opening of $43 million. While the figure secured the No. 1 spot on the charts, it represents a significant underperformance for a project with a massive $250 million production budget. When accounting for Disney’s hefty marketing spend, the total investment is at least $300 million, meaning the film will need to find a way to leg out just to reach break-even territory. Heading into the weekend, Disney was projecting a $60 million to $65 million domestic debut and $140 million globally, which would have already been considered rocky for a tentpole of this size.

David A. Gross Compares Moana Opening to Snow White and Dumbo

Global interest was similarly muted. The film launched with $52 million overseas, bringing its total global opening to $95 million, far below the $140 million worldwide figure that was hoped for. These results place the film among the weakest openings for a Disney live-action reimagining of an animated classic, landing in the same category as the 2025 release Snow White, which debuted to $42 million, and Dumbo, which opened to a lackluster result. David A. Gross, who publishes the box office newsletter FranchiseRe, noted the situation, stating: Disney invented this live-action phenomenon based on their animated films, and they’ve had remarkable success with them. But this opening isn’t close to Disney’s past remakes.

Market Saturation and Strategic Timing

The live-action Moana arrived in theaters a decade after the original 2016 animated musical and less than two years after the sequel. As noted in industry reporting, this underscores the trickiness of timing; go too soon, and there is not enough nostalgia to bring audiences back to theaters for something they have seen before and can readily watch on Disney+.

Current box office competition remains fierce. Families have been drawn to Universal/Illumination’s Minions & Monsters and Disney’s own Pixar hit Toy Story 5. Additionally, the film faced competition from global interest in the FIFA World Cup quarterfinals. Tracking had been bullish earlier in the week, with presales pointing to a $60 million-plus domestic start, but the film failed to catch a wave on Saturday when families typically come out to theaters.

Dwayne Johnson Performance Drives Positive Audience Scores

Audience Reception and Future Outlook

Despite the commercial struggle, the film has found favor with those who did attend. The production earned an A- grade on CinemaScore and a 90% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. The film also holds a 4.5/5 score in Comscore polls. Demographic data shows the film earned an overall A with women, and an A+ with the under 18 demographic. Furthermore, Screen Engine/Rentrak’s PostTrak reported a 63% definite recommend for the overall audience, with women over 25 and women overall providing a 78% and 70% definite recommend, respectively, specifically regarding Dwayne Johnson’s performance.

Disney is now looking toward long-term theatrical legs to soften the financial blow, hoping word-of-mouth will drive midweek attendance. With no further family-friendly offerings coming until Spider-Man: Brand New Day at the end of the month, there is potential for the film to leg out even with the World Cup final scheduled for next Sunday. However, given that Moana is one of the studio’s most popular franchises—boasting billions of hours streamed on Disney+, millions of toys sold and massive music streaming numbers—the capsize in its opening weekend remains a significant concern. The profitability of the animated IP will continue to rely primarily on theme park, merchandise, and other ancillary revenues.

Find more reporting in our Entertainment section.