Five European Union member states — Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands — opened negotiations with Rwanda on November 16 to build a return hub for migrants with final deportation orders, Vatican News reported.
The plan, which targets a July 2027 launch, drew immediate condemnation from the Commission of the Bishops’ Conferences of the European Union (COMECE), whose president, Bishop Mariano Crociata, likened the arrangement to deportation.
Crociata told Vatican media the initiative “has the flavor of a deportation” and sends people to “living conditions probably no better than those from which they fled.” He said the European Commission’s backing for the project confirms a long-term trend of restricting asylum access while outsourcing responsibility to third countries.
Vienna meeting launches new return hub
Christian Stocker, of the conservative People’s Party, called the November 16 meeting in Vienna a “historic paradigm shift,” according to Internazionale. Mette Frederiksen, a Social Democrat, also described it as a turning point. Six interior ministers and two heads of government attended.
The five states intend to send migrants who cannot be returned to their countries of origin to Rwanda, where they would await onward removal or, potentially, stay and receive vocational training, Vincent Biruta told reporters at the meeting.
Biruta said Rwanda views migration as a “global challenge” requiring “collective solutions” and pledged migrants would be “treated with dignity at every level.”
No financial terms have been disclosed. The United Kingdom paid £715 million (about €850 million) for a similar, ultimately abandoned, scheme before the Supreme Court blocked it in 2023 over human-rights guarantees, Internazionale reported.
Bishops warn of moral and legal risks
“The decision to outsource the placement of migrants impresses because it has the flavor of a deportation,” Crociata said in the Vatican News interview. He argued the move acknowledges Europe cannot return these people to their homelands yet refuses to protect them itself.
Avvenire, the Italian Catholic daily, cited the UK Supreme Court ruling and said that Rwanda ranks 160th on the Human Development Index.
“Paradoxical is the prospect that people who know nothing of Rwanda, and do not speak the local languages, could integrate into society and the labor market,” the paper wrote.
Domani, another Italian outlet, flagged legal obstacles distinct from Italy’s Albania protocol. The Rwanda plan targets people with final removal orders, not asylum seekers intercepted at sea, but still faces scrutiny under EU and international law, the paper reported.
Parliament hardens return rules as deaths mount
The European Parliament approved a new return regulation on November 19 by 418 votes to 218, with 30 abstentions, Vatican News reported. COMECE expressed concern the law will accelerate removals without fixing protection gaps. Hours earlier, a boat carrying about 50 migrants from Tunisia capsized off Lampedusa.
A six-year-old girl from Ivory Coast is missing; her mother is in the island’s hotspot infirmary. “Indifference has already been authoritatively denounced in the face of endless tragedies in the Mediterranean and elsewhere,” Crociata told Vatican News. He said preventing dangerous departures “is neither impossible nor unsustainable” and requires addressing root causes in countries of origin.
Deportation rates remain low despite rhetoric
Avvenire cited EU data showing fewer than 30 percent of people issued return orders actually leave. Italy carried out 4,784 repatriations in 2025, the paper said, a fraction of the irregular population estimated between 2.6 and 3.2 million across the EU and UK by the MIRREM research project.
Crociata urged a “moral reconstruction” centered on solidarity. “We need to rediscover a new sense of humanity that has at its heart not selfishness but solidarity,” he said.
🇷🇼 Five EU countries including Germany and Denmark on Monday unveiled a deal to establish a migrant deportation centre in Rwanda – the first such facility outside the bloc pic.twitter.com/GgnVu4qXLN
Dettagli sui paesi partecipanti e differenze con il piano britannico
Which countries agreed to the Rwanda return hub?
Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands launched the initiative at a Vienna meeting on November 16, 2023, according to Internazionale and Vatican News.
How does this differ from the UK-Rwanda plan?
The UK scheme aimed to send asylum seekers to Rwanda before their claims were heard. The EU plan applies only to people with final deportation orders who cannot be returned home, Internazionale reported.

What legal precedent exists?
The UK Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that Rwanda lacked sufficient human-rights safeguards, halting the British program after £715 million had been committed, Internazionale reported.
How many migrants actually leave under return orders?
Fewer than 30 percent of those issued expulsion orders in the EU comply, Avvenire cited, referencing multi-year EU statistics.
COMECE was established in 1980, replacing an earlier pastoral information service, and holds a permanent secretariat in Brussels staffed by 10 people. It is funded by the episcopal conferences of EU member states and operates through working groups including one dedicated to Migration and Asylum, the policy area at the center of the current dispute.
What did the Rwandan government say?
Vincent Biruta called migration a “global challenge” and said Rwanda could offer “a second opportunity” with dignity, according to Internazionale.
More on Rwanda
Related reading