EU Court Advisor Recommends Sentence Cuts That Could Aid Kočner

Marian Kočner received a potentially favorable signal from the Court of Justice of the European Union on Thursday, as an advocate general issued a proposal regarding the retroactive reduction of criminal sentences. The recommendation suggests that finalized prison sentences should be adjusted to align with more lenient sentencing guidelines introduced in the Slovak Criminal Code.

Proposed changes to sentencing

Advocate General Jean Richard de la Tour presented the proposal to the court, arguing that it is appropriate to apply newer, lower sentencing ranges to individuals whose convictions were already finalized under previous laws, according to Sme. The recommendation addresses whether courts should reduce existing sentences during extraordinary appeals processes, specifically following the amendments to the Criminal Code passed by the Slovak coalition in March 2024.

Did You Know? The current proceedings at the European court were initiated after the Slovak Constitutional Court submitted a formal inquiry regarding these sentencing adjustments in December of last year.

The path to a final verdict

While the advocate general’s proposal provides a significant indicator, it does not constitute a final ruling. The Fourth Chamber of the court is expected to deliver its decision within the coming weeks.

In the vast majority of cases, the court follows the recommendations of the advocate general, whose findings are based on related case law, legal reviews, and analysis. If the court adopts this stance, it could lead to the retroactive reduction of sentences for convicted individuals, including Kočner.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of the European advocate general in this case?

The advocate general provides a legal opinion and recommendation to the court based on case law and analysis. While their proposal is not a binding verdict, the court follows this guidance in the vast majority of cases.

What specific legal change is under review?

The court is examining whether sentences that were already finalized should be reduced to match the more lenient sentencing ranges introduced in the March 2024 amendment of the Slovak Criminal Code.

When can a final decision be expected?

The Fourth Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European Union is expected to reach a decision on the matter within the next few weeks.