European Court Bars Romanian Lawyer for Two Years Over AI-Generated Fabricated Case Law

A Romanian lawyer has been barred for two years from representing litigants before the European Court of Human Rights after submitting artificial intelligence-generated arguments containing fabricated case law, according to an official media release issued on Thursday.

Court President Mattias Guyomar approved a reasoned proposal from a chamber of the court to exclude the advocate. The observations submitted in the case featured numerous errors concerning existing legal precedents, including references to nonexistent cases and fictitious paragraphs within genuine judgments.

Other citations pointed to irrelevant case law that plainly contradicted the submissions they were meant to support. The lawyer acknowledged using AI tools to draft the documents, describing the mistakes as inaccuracies and citation errors.

Chamber Findings on Professional Duties

The chamber determined that the filings displayed a pattern of repeated substantive errors rather than isolated mistakes. This conduct fell short of professional and ethical duties required by both the court and domestic law.

Before making the decision, the chamber invited comments from the lawyer, the Romanian government, and the Romanian National Bar Association. Rules governing the legal profession mandate that advocates act as reasonably competent professionals with a high level of professional prudence.

This standard required the lawyer to independently verify all arguments and case-law references against authoritative sources like the court database. The chamber said that no checks were carried out for certain references, and many errors would have been easily detected through a cursory database search.

Impact on Court Administration

The failures caused prejudice to the administration of justice by forcing the court to spend considerable time verifying observations and corresponding with stakeholders. This workload was deemed incompatible with the court’s real functions under the European Convention on Human Rights.

The conduct met the exceptional circumstances threshold required to exclude an advocate from representing or assisting a party. The exclusion does not prevent the lawyer from having representation rights restored in the future, and she acted alongside a second representative whose status remains unaffected.

When did the European Court of Human Rights enforce the ban?

The President of the Court decided to exclude the Romanian lawyer on November 13, 2026, following a reasoned proposal from the chamber.

How long is the legal representative barred from the court?

The Romanian lawyer is barred from representing or assisting litigants before the European Court of Human Rights for a period of two years.

Established in 1959 as the judicial arm of the Council of Europe, the European Court of Human Rights became a full-time institution in 1998 after Protocol 11 abolished the European Commission of Human Rights. The court, based in Strasbourg, oversees compliance with the European Convention on Human Rights for the organisation’s 46 member states.

Did the lawyer admit to using artificial intelligence tools?

Yes, the lawyer acknowledged using AI tools to draft the observations, though she characterized the resulting mistakes as inaccuracies and citation errors.