Anne Donaghy, the 56-year-old former local authority chief executive, appeared at Ballymena Magistrates’ Court on Monday to face charges regarding the alleged deletion of electronic records during her tenure, according to court reports. Alongside her, 49-year-old Aaron McClelland faces a single count of attempting to delete records. The proceedings, presided over by District Judge Alana McSorley, centre on Freedom of Information (FOI) compliance and high-stakes political correspondence surrounding the Northern Ireland Protocol.
Court Details and the Charges Involving Former Council Chief Executive
The trial revolves around three specific offences brought against Donaghy, located at Clonmore Road, Dungannon, involving the deletion, attempted deletion, and procurement of the deletion of electronic mail. According to the prosecution, the disputed correspondence was a February 2, 2021 forwarding of a letter originally sent by Donaghy to a UK Cabinet Office official on January 3, 2021. That initial letter detailed operational concerns regarding the Northern Ireland Protocol at Larne Port and the safety of municipal staff following the introduction of the post-Brexit Irish Sea border.
Before the proceedings commenced, a solicitor representing Donaghy stated that she would vehemently contest what they termed “these three technical offences.” The two-day trial examines whether the digital removal of the correspondence was executed intentionally to evade statutory disclosure obligations under freedom of information laws.
Political Tension at Larne Port and Freedom of Information Requests
The disputed communication originated during a period of intense political fallout following the implementation of post-Brexit trading arrangements. Municipal employees had been temporarily withdrawn from Larne Port after reports of sinister graffiti and alleged threats. Prosecution arguments highlighted that Donaghy drafted the Cabinet Office letter after receiving advice from Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) politicians, including MPs Ian Paisley, Sammy Wilson, and Jeffrey Donaldson. The correspondence was subsequently shared with various DUP figures, including former first minister Arlene Foster, then-agriculture minister Edwin Poots, and then-economy minister Gordon Lyons.
On February 8, 2021, the local authority received an initial media FOI request asking for copies of letters sent to the UK government concerning the protocol and threats to personnel. Officials initially refused that request, citing health, safety, and security grounds. By April, amidst mounting political and media scrutiny and questioning at a Stormont committee by Alliance MLA John Blair regarding why she consulted exclusively with DUP representatives, prosecutors stated Donaghy grew concerned about being perceived as “the DUP’s person.”
Audio Recordings and Police Interviews Presented by the Prosecution
To substantiate the charges, the prosecution played audio recordings captured on a recording device belonging to Donaghy’s assistant. In the audio, the former chief executive is heard instructing her assistant to delete the message sent to Foster. When informed that the council’s internal FOI team upstairs retained a duplicate copy, Donaghy responded with “Oh no,” according to court testimony. A separate audio recording presented to the bench captured a different assistant telling McClelland, “I am not deleting any emails.”
During police interviews, Donaghy acknowledged asking her assistant to delete the electronic communication. She maintained that leaks within the administration presented a risk that Foster’s personal contact details might leak into the public domain. She added that she understood physical hard copies remained preserved while requesting the removal of the digital file. The trial before District Judge McSorley continues.
Did you know?
Frequently Asked Questions
Who are the defendants in the Ballymena Magistrates’ Court trial?
The defendants are Anne Donaghy (56), the former local authority chief executive, and Aaron McClelland (49), who faces a single count of attempting to delete an electronic record.
What specific document triggered the prosecution?
The prosecution centres on an email forwarded to former first minister Arlene Foster on February 2, 2021, which contained a letter sent to the UK Cabinet Office regarding the Northern Ireland Protocol and Larne Port safety concerns.
What are the legal defences raised in court?
A solicitor representing Donaghy stated prior to the trial that she would vehemently contest the charges, while police interviews noted her explanation that she sought the removal of the digital copy to protect personal email details from leaking, knowing physical backups existed.
Join the Discussion: What are your thoughts on public sector transparency and information management? Share your perspective in the comments below, or explore our latest reporting for ongoing updates on local government accountability.
Related reading