The Hamburg Regional Court has issued a preliminary injunction barring OpenSanctions from stating in Germany that billionaire Alisher Usmanov is subject to European Union sanctions.
The November 18 ruling, issued without an oral hearing, follows findings that the database continued to display the listing weeks after the EU formally removed him.
- The injunction carries a potential fine of up to €250,000 for each breach, according to IntelliNews.
- The court set the value in dispute at €20,000 for the case, numbered 324 O 400/26.
- OpenSanctions had already deleted the entry but continues to defend its presentation, as reported by journalarta.com.
The court’s 24th civil chamber determined that the database operator functions as the author of its data rather than a neutral technical distributor. Judges said that while the company rapidly captures new listings, it only removes delisted names once the consolidated text is published.
“In the chamber’s view, such a procedure cannot be equated with purely technical distribution,” the court wrote, according to IntelliNews. Because the company “knowingly accepts that its presentation does not correspond to the current sanctions regime,” it cannot rely on typical press-law protections for official sources.
The order specifically targets two entries that appeared on the Usmanov profile on October 6, which cited the Council of the European Union and the European Commission’s financial services directorate. “This is a statement of fact which, for the time of the contested access on October 6, 2026, is undisputedly untrue,” the chamber wrote.

The company previously argued that its tabular presentation merely reflected the state of its sources. The court rejected this, stating the format “contains an independent statement and not merely a reference to the source situation,” as reported by Yahoo.com. Usmanov was removed from the EU sanctions list on September 22 as part of a wider agreement to renew measures against approximately 3,000 other individuals and entities.
Legal Representation and Court Findings
The injunction was secured following an application by Usmanov’s lawyers at the Hamburg-based firm Steinhöfel.
The ruling said that the tabular presentation “contains an independent statement and not merely a reference to the source situation,” effectively placing responsibility for the accuracy of the data on the operator.

The Average Reader’s Interpretation
Although the company had already deleted the contested presentation, the ruling records that the firm was represented in the proceedings and continued to defend its practices.
Negotiated Removals
The decision to drop Usmanov and fellow billionaire Mikhail Fridman from the EU sanctions list followed diplomatic negotiations. EU ambassadors agreed on September 22 to remove them as the price of renewing the remaining sanctions on the other individuals and entities for three years rather than six months.
France had advocated for Usmanov’s removal citing national security, while Luxembourg sought the same for Fridman. Latvia, the final holdout in the negotiations, abstained from the decision before subsequently placing both men on its own national sanctions list.
OpenSanctions is a Berlin-based database that aggregates information on sanctioned entities, politically exposed persons, and financial crime enforcement subjects. To compile its data, the organization employs open-source software to gather and structure records from various international sources. The Hamburg Regional Court ruled that this process functions as authorship rather than neutral distribution because the platform does not merely mirror official documents, but instead creates an independent tabular presentation.
By choosing to retain specific entries until a consolidated text is officially published—rather than reflecting the immediate status of a delisting—the court determined that the company knowingly presents information that does not align with the current legal reality, thus disqualifying it from standard press-law protections.
| Entity | Sanction Status | Date of Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Alisher Usmanov | EU Delisted | September 22, 2026 |
| Alisher Usmanov | Latvian National List | September 22, 2026 |
The ruling, which applies only within Germany, remains open to objection by the Berlin-based company. The court placed the costs of the proceedings on OpenSanctions Datenbanken GmbH.
OpenSanctions’ documentation currently states that removals “take effect when the consolidated text is published, not on the day of the delisting act,” and advises listed persons to “allow up to one week” for changes to appear, according to IntelliNews. The company’s Usmanov profile, last updated on November 16, now excludes the EU listing but reflects national measures from Latvia, the UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Ukraine.